找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 2208|回复: 3

【资料】Koreanfilm.org Critics Poll--2005

[复制链接]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
发表于 2005-8-6 07:44 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
2005
& n  t3 e7 ]- R
' a: F: w0 S, ^( j+ h. vThe Aggressives   
1 g5 K" K  [# D( q1 M   
$ V1 S( |. q% }; k3 OTom Giammarco  两颗半星       $ a/ t& U- V; L$ _/ N5 u- w
Darcy Paquet      两颗星  ! w4 @; K* E0 @: N. g& U! G
8 ]/ X( M. C* r; \# x, a7 V+ D
  Good stunts. Flat, uninteresting characters.
2 P( H9 U+ P5 ?  @, ~   Has technical flair, but none of the poetry of Take Care Of My Cat.- H8 `$ g9 A+ E+ A/ [
: ]: y) g5 [2 A) {2 {% L

; T4 ?; |( B7 f. ]    0 r; {  m4 c/ r1 P
Another Public Enemy   (公共之敌 2)
. J+ ]5 M# @0 ~7 B- T   
* N/ S& V3 j  a5 L; K: ETom Giammarco  三颗星
( k" Q3 W9 D* R+ D8 b; iDarcy Paquet      两颗半星; g$ x/ _3 r/ w8 e# P& S" _

7 j- Y7 \. |% S6 [0 NNot a bad action movie but LONG. I kept checking my watch.
: e. S$ B! X. n& ]5 USuffers from a lack of efficiency. # |3 H4 J/ h, W0 p+ s6 k9 b
    ! R* J/ A- l& s9 H/ s7 I' v+ G
Antarctic Journal   (南极日记)
3 ~# j6 v+ z7 S6 i1 g& V$ a   1 Q2 x7 [7 Q2 c# w6 ]( i
Tom Giammarco    三颗星
* g6 y, z0 {0 K' S) dAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星
: l+ o& ?2 \. K- U  d8 }Darcy Paquet   两颗半星
# u( C& e- U9 M' ^8 h
. c# y) U3 `9 Y6 m/ x) tExpected so much more. Curse of the Korean blockbusters resumes.
+ t6 D, f, M" X) KLeft me cold.
- ?) @: M" u! @% T1 v9 B" G- W$ K2 hStarts off nice, but then loses its compass. % a4 ^# I, H4 L4 b* h1 u
% r; r0 T/ J$ \
  e5 ?$ r8 x1 R
A Bittersweet Life   (甜蜜的人生)
/ m7 l( Z" g  R  R   # b" Z; _% g3 M% z! K* K- j$ R) r
Paolo Bertolin      四颗星9 i1 R" N1 t' e
Tom Giammarco  四颗星
7 g% D( s+ n. G. Z- K3 b# fDarcy Paquet  三颗半星. q, G+ }6 r! h8 `" z
Mark Russell   两颗半星2 b& K0 v1 b* p1 l& U( L
, S" a# Y& J9 K( f# y
Kim's lavish visuals enriched by full-fledged dramatic consistency. 2 q$ A% b* J1 ]1 ?9 Z$ J* k; Q
Stylish violence and excellent characterizations. 4 \4 m  F0 o1 I. V& W1 g$ U3 v3 n: k
Movie to show friends who liked Old Boy.9 u  B& r# a' c) R% g7 T! E: Z
Slick-looking but empty, with endless, pointless violence.
! q1 K  i& m+ q2 r: F! w% u* T5 E2 _( d! _/ `
The Bow   
. ^$ {& a6 d4 p7 f   
( i9 G% {- ]( n+ @( qPaolo Bertolin   两颗半星
) l. @% f% x1 B4 p8 `3 WDarcy Paquet   一颗半星
9 E6 R* a3 v& F4 G2 O) @0 c% v* g1 W9 l; C5 u
Feels like a mild "best of" for festivals and Western audiences.
- D2 @: Y# q3 Z- i" y& a1 r& YKim Ki-duk on autopilot. 7 v( N, h, i# u) r0 N( }  V, C
1 r  C; |' f4 o# e
& v; z" R3 R1 o. N( w
Brainwave   
2 _( s* L. ?  \. }- b2 _   
  U& d4 M+ b1 y8 K( N; [: Y, ^Tom Giammarco    三颗半星
) j+ `& A9 ^  d3 ^/ W% `# iAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星
+ `4 ^0 d1 k& v1 Z4 X: X4 U& r% ], H$ l3 l& E, @
Enjoyable low-budget sci-fi but its vision was beyond its budget.
9 C) Z) j" \; QNow I know why Terminator was not shot with a handycam. 4 u( T: [' O# e0 z6 u8 a
: x1 S3 o5 U4 y; w
   
' {2 ^& y. q! c& c& Z8 o" WCrying Fist   (哭泣的拳头)4 U+ f2 _8 r$ m; h! E
   
/ P& B7 V' \1 iTom Giammarco    四颗星+ E; ^' B- r3 u
Adrien Gombeaud  三颗半星
3 w) R" Z- n  c1 H) CDarcy Paquet       四颗星
9 c! y1 b6 v& ?& K
* n5 L' H! a2 |8 nRyoo Seung-beom's acting elevates the film from good to great. % @- B7 L+ H: x' f0 I, j) Z
Hurts so good. ) }, _2 \* A1 ^4 x! z
Gives the boxing film genre a punch in the ribs. 4 ~# I/ g+ V1 h! s4 p. V

4 s- q. \3 ^+ B3 V# }% k' J   
8 n2 ]" e7 G" `: m% |6 ~Feathers in the Wind (Git)   (风之羽)
2 c* T( \+ \% B$ A) r: d7 J   ' ]) }- e+ c, E7 h+ j- Z! U
Paolo Bertolin 三颗半星4 t: h1 Q3 t* L: `' i5 G
Davide Cazzaro  四颗星, z7 K6 r7 j& V9 f+ Z* _1 Z
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星 3 r8 f' w' T' O8 z+ [+ {
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星
, M- d+ v2 a( d8 B$ O5 Z% A/ {3 LMark Russell  三颗星: V, ?( \/ [; i  Y- \/ p2 Y

7 t7 F" j9 n+ r$ fLight as a feather, a small film often touched by grace. " d& f+ E0 I( V3 K" u
Definitely one of the best Korean films produced in 2004. 1 H) E( v9 r( p+ J" @
Beautiful images, expertly paced story and interesting characters# [1 n. c' v9 o  {  `
Korea's most exciting screen romance in a very long time.
+ J+ v, `8 m5 ]0 INice little film, but nothing special.
& m+ L! f6 |0 D/ t9 ~
$ V' q' F# }  m6 uGreen Chair   (绿椅子)
5 W& B6 O* j3 |1 B8 R$ N   9 x. b/ Z/ j  B
Paolo Bertolin 四颗星7 m6 Y# y* S0 o' H9 M7 l: w
Davide Cazzaro  三颗星
, Q$ m% ?+ m2 j" F) e( J0 I6 aFilmbrain   三颗星) H6 ]1 |* H; e% N  j$ s7 @
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星8 ~1 \1 U# a$ I# }% T
Adam Hartzell 三颗星# n% g2 `" }7 y4 V8 X# ~
Darcy Paquet  四颗星& I8 c2 w* n/ v8 {) F

2 I. K( f$ g) j) h  ?$ e& V7 a1 a5 d6 q; U- N' n
Asks the right questions in the proper manner. Heart-warming sex.
: B$ b* L7 ^9 y$ _8 `. MGood development of the story and fresh ideas. A little long.
" T  l' J0 X. m! pDaring, unconventional, sexy, and full of unexpected pleasures.
8 h3 l0 L) M% S" x3 {$ g1 z8 MThis would have been much better as a short film. Last 20 mins good. : T. j6 Y3 c' s( f0 k# N8 k
Park peeps behind the Green Chair and finds more Park particulars. : h; q' ]/ Z4 E% y6 z3 g/ s
Irreverent and obnoxious, but still very touching.
- m" u2 P- W  o5 z4 M3 w
9 C# Z3 r( Y- ]( Q9 h2 P   
8 S# P5 l+ W7 D9 Y; m5 U/ EIf You Were Me 2   (如果你是我 2 )
' t( Y) H& \4 Y# `& }3 F   
* p5 n7 E  W; J( k4 J* s$ u; p  GTom Giammarco  四颗半星- \2 O- i8 O3 F7 M2 r9 `" u- j+ z
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星% h+ F5 ?; X. z
( X5 k8 a6 d6 N' p* g- o" ^* N
Arguably better than the original. Tightly focused storytelling.
, h% O4 }- q- t' U9 n7 jA well-formed omnibus (which is rare). Jung Ji-woo's is my favorite.
' U1 Z# r$ W# H8 m8 E: I. v3 D+ F; w+ r

9 i5 A  M# L, t    4 ^9 ~. f: R' Z) s
Innocent Steps   ( 舞女纯情)) G1 c0 i* E" i: Z: [3 i
   
" w8 D4 V3 c; i* z9 Q- MTom Giammarco  两颗半星
0 w. u1 O! x" D) wDarcy Paquet  一颗半星
: n* _( K3 B3 M8 c9 t( J8 }$ C6 r; T: w& o* g: T# W" j/ L" w
Disappointing and cliche.   b3 C5 w4 t" f+ q# m' l6 I
I wish the screenwriter had just let them dance. 7 y, r: ~8 s# h, a

2 |: k* G/ f8 l; C4 v- ]+ X7 \" B
5 b9 K* G% U, M6 C8 f; {- U& t
  a5 ]  r- e* o4 e0 b/ @Jenny, Juno   
9 Z* t' y3 Z9 j   
1 q4 C4 y3 N- c/ i, Y! X. ~0 VTom Giammarco  一颗星
' _# ~: S* ?' h) ?: h6 bKyu Hyun  Kim  一颗半星- h7 f1 s6 ~" `2 m% J) X  I7 d' B
Elif Kaya  两颗半星
" ?) {4 a% J+ I; q: x3 x- ~% gDarcy Paquet  两颗星
" {2 `3 F9 \( J5 r, Q
1 O, J7 @+ a# L9 j" Y2 PTreats the subject of early-teen pregnancy much too lightly. / T' o3 k" F  _8 [
Good Lord. Makes Blue Lagoon look like Umbrellas of Cherbourg .
  X7 D, V6 i3 `/ _6 S+ FStylish, feel good film, not much else is there though. 8 s9 l, U; ^( o2 a4 M  e7 U
I was enjoying this movie, and then I started to hate it.
9 f0 N' |) H" d0 H6 K# I5 y3 \! R2 R( d. P0 Y, _
   
1 ~5 W) k# [0 I; {7 [, N& ~Mapado   (麻婆岛)
/ O9 P8 c) X% f6 y8 m   
) h7 ?2 H: I# y  l$ {Paolo Bertolin 两颗星4 u0 E& y. e8 P
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星8 l; @2 H& ~$ j, T9 F
2 c7 r% n5 M2 v& G+ K; x  t9 W- h
Formulaic characters and contrived plot. Obnoxious and trivial.
- K. f0 c/ J$ g. [5 i7 cNeed to turn off your brain to get through this comedy.
4 D- {( {' f/ d  Y& M1 _% `& |/ U+ T5 v6 s% Z4 s1 g
   
( F) V+ B; b4 e) j3 h  ~2 a& eMarathon   (马拉松)
: m# E5 J/ Q: y6 r: S% E/ |9 ?   3 K6 s) V& r5 O$ n
Paolo Bertolin  一颗半
, K; A6 e5 t: [6 N: H! ^7 ?+ a+ DTom Giammarco  四颗半; z( e* g2 y$ k4 c; c

6 Y/ N, S1 f, a0 }( L+ _Typical Korean woman-basher: it's all mum's fault! Cho overdoes it.
/ g$ E* _7 f& H' S2 C! [Excellent performances shine in this touching story.
, V4 w/ o+ ~+ I1 @# Y# D4 Y* @
6 j  C/ q, |. R8 z0 e: |2 d
7 ]3 K( @: P, ~3 [4 P- M: hMy Boyfriend is Type-B   (我的B型男友)
4 s! [# g8 V) \2 [# |$ j   
1 p- v3 k8 K( R4 i% `( ]0 X9 aTom Giammarco  . 两颗星
( Y  R& ]/ ?6 E$ `) C$ t7 F9 GElif Kaya   两颗星
  I  K$ w: r2 N, ~+ oDarcy Paquet  一颗半星
" n* s! u9 _8 Z! S. }    - J+ M% |0 j6 ]
Couldn't stand the characters. No chemistry between the leads
6 I8 \: D/ U7 D( [" ?& D2 ~Lacklustre rom com, only if you like any of the lead actors." i7 v5 W$ C* h
How about that Lotte product placement?
" k) z# I6 w2 p* |
2 s2 g1 s  J) Q6 PPossible Changes   (可能的变化)5 ~9 n* m( e1 s0 ^
   
+ u/ n: a' b: X- ZDavide Cazzaro 一颗星! }* o+ U8 @6 s) K4 H
Tom Giammarco  一颗星9 j% Y9 f$ g4 B& }) l
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星) e9 N) ?, N9 g2 p( _( ]% t
4 h: X. Q( D' C! j4 o8 M- ?
Former assistant to Hong Sang-soo tried to make a Hong film. 6 W! t: Q1 E7 J+ v) D, P
Somber, depressing, stagnant and pointless.
# u4 y+ o. T; T. c' n2 x2 l; bMaybe I missed something. I don't think so.
/ z# E& ^$ C5 w3 z
8 T$ F5 V: I  n
: Y4 y8 w9 L% u' a4 l+ B
" `3 ]  q* A8 N# X( Q) c' S( v
& z7 [) L& H8 I, G3 y: wThe President's Last Bang   (那时代,那些人)$ L% H9 b6 `6 y
   # _7 O" }$ V/ v- J( j2 m
Paolo Bertolin  三颗半星4 ^5 k. p, l3 B( |7 b
James Brown  三颗半星
& o: H7 I2 k: \- b9 UDavide Cazzaro  四颗半星- {6 Q$ H# Y9 r# m
Filmbrain 四颗半星6 `7 M6 y% e, ?/ O6 c
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星
( g  K( u1 L7 C* KMark Russell  四颗星# H. V9 A+ J2 L
Boris Trbic  三颗半星: S6 n; x. \$ X: y9 s+ y
5 P1 d. y# I; {2 w9 F; H, |
Im knows how to dare, and his ambition and bravery deserve praise.
, q; s( L; S7 SHip, intrepid piece but its irreverence is just a touch too zealous. * T0 V) I, T, s) e' B, N
Witty, provocative and mordent. A "must not miss" Korean film. " C( |7 |& v  P$ T/ h0 {8 G4 Z
Brilliant political satire that easily ranks with the best. % k! t3 X/ o5 S0 h
Baek Yoon-shik is a god, and Im Sang-soo is a master.
. Y/ ^; z) \" I9 h) cMaybe not great history, but a great film. Dark and funny. 9 }; v/ A+ ^5 k8 J) O
Undressing fascism can be fun. Gloomy and entertaining.  " ^. l+ p2 a) A8 t; Q( Y

$ R! |  f2 W2 I. }) A3 V. x9 w! y7 H   
5 H) ?2 l+ n6 m9 y9 LRed Eye   (红眼); @% o9 i' {/ V6 {  O. l, V5 O: L
   
+ _8 U0 Y% z, n) i" J* WTom Giammarco  两颗星
, W5 H- ^0 [8 ]Kyu Hyun  Kim  两颗半星
) P: N2 i2 s7 [0 QDarcy Paquet  一颗半星* s% `: k( O/ t* k3 p3 H

6 }- A8 K  y  p& H3 s0 a An embarrassment to ghosts everywhere.
7 v  e, x5 o' lNo Oriental Express, but I rather fancied the train setting.
' H" U$ I! w. G: P# J9 c5 sNice cast, but none of the emotions in the film hit home.
9 a+ r  e' C: T6 g: ~) a# e4 o' ]6 |: k
   
1 N9 H6 a7 D" cThe Red Shoes   (红鞋)$ ?2 O8 O4 c0 z' e, N
   5 A3 A% l% k4 ]% S' _' o
Tom Giammarco  三颗半星7 }' q3 `- `# x( u7 I$ S+ a
Kyu Hyun  Kim  三颗星2 `) F; P6 W% V( c
Darcy Paquet  两颗半星+ ?0 x1 k5 |! @' z7 l

8 @* o6 z& N' m' e0 K+ G9 `Kim Hye-su is excellent/Plot has many holes but manages to scare.
9 v0 e; J) m, I' tThe shoes are, uh, pink. At least Kim Hye-su dances to her tune. ' ^1 i  \% L7 D( z
An A for style, a C- for enlightened creativity. ' D' A9 s/ |1 q: F' k

+ Q/ \: p- y" @# h1 W( N5 `- U  `- s+ z& I' \; I0 |5 u! ?
Road   (公路)5 \8 N) R6 U0 n$ G
   
0 r2 j" I" s# g$ d2 R1 RDavide Cazzaro  三颗星* i, L2 C' K4 y4 p/ F  |7 _2 u
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星
4 w5 H/ n0 l$ d, Q/ QDarcy Paquet  三颗星
4 ~* J5 D. v$ _. Q+ \! q+ k1 e+ p$ b% B0 m6 ^
Nothing very new but Bae Chang-ho shows his talent and experience.& s+ u1 d( d7 W: S  j4 L
Great cinematography & story. Not perfect due to lead actress. + H  x+ ?. v' L/ t4 e" ~# ^" O
Its slow-building emotional power is its greatest strength. 0 s8 E9 x. I8 ?4 f6 W" f. j

& [, m' ~% \2 b+ g1 Q# v) U3 M2 ]$ d/ B5 j6 }

! z+ h- d7 K: v/ N( U: E& NSpying Cam   
; @: a  I1 F9 J0 {0 o1 }( W- h   
+ J  u% d; j% a1 w6 U! dPaolo Bertolin  四颗星
% O* L1 o! H) T) S2 d  a$ y) VDarcy Paquet  两颗半星& X" P! j5 [$ @; Q+ }7 U" F
4 T: D$ t0 Y7 R; I" d3 F6 T+ |' ?# k
Korean political background, yet universal ethics in a great film.
2 I+ X. {' X% p% c: X; B: SMade with passion but not quite as much precision. # E9 E' Y5 S1 F" [; J

  W: V  ]" ~0 e& H$ ~9 x: z& z, a7 c7 z, z
   
2 K- [/ N5 ^2 L6 \' OTale of Cinema   (剧场前)
; h8 l: i% B  O) Y8 i' P   
8 ?" K; j9 ^4 N# t$ O) BPaolo Bertolin 两颗星
/ {6 ?) |- e5 ]6 K  cDarcy Paquet  三颗半星" a3 E. k& k# c, W1 J2 a2 z$ {
Mark Russell  两颗星
- W7 P5 b2 H8 V3 G: h3 q+ ^5 C, f' A6 k: _7 b! Q% E
An utter disappointment. Is Hong running out of inspiration? ) y1 h# _! O4 @. m+ {; _$ `0 R4 {
Do I detect a tiny glimpse of optimism in this film?
& k+ b/ O5 _' ?$ e& y% `  m..ooOOoo....ooOOoo... Love that zoom. Dull and uninspired. ! q1 S* b7 E, O( [4 g1 {! e
- C# z; X! j* S) Q( G6 D  j
2 S  |* [* M0 i7 K1 [

% [6 a1 j  H2 N2 J- L   
: _  j9 m# a( G8 Q/ Y0 B1 FThis Charming Girl   (女子晴惠)- f. v  v" Z5 P, A# z( [6 e
     I3 q: B' @  F4 M. Y" P
Davide Cazzaro  四颗星; u2 k- v" k5 ?/ p8 Y6 Y$ {
Filmbrain  三颗半星' [, I5 M1 O$ m* e$ j' ~: W4 y
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星1 Y  X1 H# u1 C
Adrien Gombeaud  五颗星
9 x5 {7 o) G9 jAdam Hartzell  三颗半星5 {. R9 H4 J# t$ H
Kyu Hyun  Kim  四颗星
" l5 q* v4 |1 q& h( tDarcy Paquet  三颗半星6 P' |3 K% E: n/ ~
2 ^4 j" p( n  Z
Probably the best debut of 2004. Let's keep an eye on Lee Yoon-ki.
1 [$ f& f$ A  G1 gSmall, quiet, subtle. The kind of film we need to see more of. 7 m5 p2 z: v6 J! v3 ]6 _( N- v8 q
Amazing film giving intricate details of the life of one woman.
2 l6 e# ]' N  \$ a: \" TShe walks in beauty.
0 o  p9 w5 a- GNot a jumped-up postal girl, but an intriguing character study. ( J  i1 R8 m, Z3 v" ^3 Y3 g$ m
Finally, a filmic antidote to the "YOU WANNA DIE?" Sassy Girls.
" h! t- a+ s1 N: ?( h0 F& C/ w; j  QA quiet but strong film. Kim Ji-soo is worth following
. i9 H- P% g& F7 Y; v3 a
& M0 Z3 E: k" ~$ K# @% H[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2005-8-6 at 10:37 ]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-6 07:54 | 显示全部楼层

包括了很多2005年以来放映的韩片,好像截止到六月份

以上只是KOREANFILM.ORG这个网站中的人员的一些投票,他们的口味偏专家一些,也许和一般的观众有点点不一样.即便里面的人,有时候针对一部电影,也会有截然不同的结果.
  j& Y8 M3 |0 t7 P' V- v
0 u) G8 M& Q8 y( A# |- J看了这么多,感觉好像到2005年的六月份为止,在超过一百万人次的电影中,<那时代,那些人>获得这些影评人的很高的评价,<甜蜜人生>和<哭泣的拳头>也是评价也很不错的,小众电影中,<女子晴惠>,<风之羽><绿椅子>等也是评价非常不错.<南极日记>比较惨,是输了票房,又输了影评的那种两头不落好的电影(成功的商业电影也不是好做的),<公共之敌2>,<麻婆岛>至少还有票房在,<马拉松>好象评价很极端,个人认为还是艺术质量还不错的大众片.金基德和洪尚秀今年的作品似乎并不被这些影评人欣赏.* X, `' {5 T! E* S0 h( E
* ]8 l0 N: q& f( _( x3 E  Z4 Z
[ Last edited by lwang on 2005-8-6 at 08:03 ]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
发表于 2005-8-6 11:24 | 显示全部楼层
目前截止,,<那时代,那些人>的确是上半年的翘楚之作!!
/ ]: r( m/ S9 D8 U+ V# z8 B$ _他们对<哭泣的拳头>评价不错,但个人感觉真是一般啊!!柳没什么特色!
此时无声胜有声

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-7 10:28 | 显示全部楼层
<亲切的金子>也许会是下半年最重要的作品了. 就目前所知道的这些有名的导演的作品来看,也就这部值得看了.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

联系我们|手机版|小黑屋|韩剧社区 ( 蜀ICP备14001718号 )

JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!

GMT+8, 2025-1-22 08:27 , Processed in 0.036746 second(s), 22 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.5

© 2001-2024 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表