找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 2220|回复: 3

【资料】Koreanfilm.org Critics Poll--2005

[复制链接]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
发表于 2005-8-6 07:44 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
2005+ i' I0 ~6 |) h% Q2 J0 m/ K4 j
/ Y( e8 k* M* Q! A+ y
The Aggressives   
# L& J! w" p8 I3 J* G   
; H9 ]) x& o6 Q. l( W$ \Tom Giammarco  两颗半星       & p; N% X6 w3 R
Darcy Paquet      两颗星  
" R3 h) X/ I& T5 Z2 \# p" A1 M2 Q$ Y) H* b# a/ C8 x+ o& Y4 r3 I+ Q
  Good stunts. Flat, uninteresting characters.3 H( s8 _( q- |0 [6 L& h) f$ H% D
   Has technical flair, but none of the poetry of Take Care Of My Cat.6 \, L1 w& k& q! R# R/ k
: a( E" Y) W  ~8 _* u+ V) W6 X

* t& u/ ^" W3 {5 E. j& d/ b    & O  P8 x4 u- _7 P
Another Public Enemy   (公共之敌 2)' c# r3 u; w/ {* G+ X
   % V0 w5 w; Y  R8 g0 f
Tom Giammarco  三颗星, R; q( A& y4 a
Darcy Paquet      两颗半星
8 l! H8 @0 q) u% E
! b. ]' a: e7 B$ F1 s, M9 A: SNot a bad action movie but LONG. I kept checking my watch.
: C" u1 F" Q: x) \Suffers from a lack of efficiency. 1 S3 M2 ~3 Z2 P$ i7 D
   
- l+ Z: d# ~% F# v4 pAntarctic Journal   (南极日记)  v" P3 _6 I! l$ x8 h1 E
   
6 K3 [8 d$ C9 S0 ]Tom Giammarco    三颗星* h/ @/ N7 h* [8 _% o
Adrien Gombeaud  一颗星
3 K3 q* z& H; T1 B( Z+ lDarcy Paquet   两颗半星
, F, M; K. N; Q$ F% `2 c8 P( R: X8 T. T* g
Expected so much more. Curse of the Korean blockbusters resumes.
) w" C* I4 }: V, s" uLeft me cold. % n% N: |/ N' y% k6 j
Starts off nice, but then loses its compass. 8 u+ U- \0 r1 k, Y/ [. U8 F
0 e* ^. b1 U1 f  T

  J. c+ b$ F3 e2 w2 UA Bittersweet Life   (甜蜜的人生)
# o" Q. A) u7 e' ]     i" g) o; K! j
Paolo Bertolin      四颗星
+ s; H" U0 U* y* Z, f( eTom Giammarco  四颗星
( {* p+ }4 |9 q9 FDarcy Paquet  三颗半星
% T6 [" B! ]; ]3 I0 bMark Russell   两颗半星
9 j' l' G" k$ E9 M- g! N" z& i- W6 ~* ]. t' N, a
Kim's lavish visuals enriched by full-fledged dramatic consistency.
* Y" L5 x: A) D, }3 E. D* TStylish violence and excellent characterizations. 7 L& ?! @4 }6 P  u7 G  O0 o
Movie to show friends who liked Old Boy.
( t+ l0 U( P% t2 |0 c+ XSlick-looking but empty, with endless, pointless violence.
: A5 U; d7 u" N8 @: l/ t
3 g8 W* Q$ L+ a2 K) q: oThe Bow   1 G& `( ~$ l* ?9 d  I6 u! W
   $ _4 r6 }/ U: p: G9 i; v
Paolo Bertolin   两颗半星
# {8 U! z2 |' l: ?7 v0 k# zDarcy Paquet   一颗半星/ Z- Z6 \# d, Z5 h' E" \& C6 W

; @6 e" I# O" c, z5 a: o. ZFeels like a mild "best of" for festivals and Western audiences.
6 w) ?7 s# i; G/ PKim Ki-duk on autopilot. 7 p+ b/ |5 g# s

4 I; A, k" u* N6 h+ e: }; `% G' m- H2 {! e
Brainwave   & J% ]* {* ~4 t# C: Z+ g+ f' e
   
' ^  }. \) f: K- j) v4 x1 kTom Giammarco    三颗半星* V9 P3 K% l, p" T- M. d- A
Adrien Gombeaud  一颗星
( V# s8 p# j! P9 X- v/ C$ {2 r! ~' \3 J. \
Enjoyable low-budget sci-fi but its vision was beyond its budget.
' i7 q+ B: z7 I# C( J' XNow I know why Terminator was not shot with a handycam. ' N1 F& k: o! q: g+ e
& a/ O) i+ a: L* W, M
    & ]. r" O* Y% r2 f  Q
Crying Fist   (哭泣的拳头)
2 V& \, C$ Y5 K/ a0 d1 T. M/ P5 ]& G6 I   4 u2 L' u$ Z& ~* C; d) z. b6 g
Tom Giammarco    四颗星
$ l* i8 L5 v; r$ gAdrien Gombeaud  三颗半星6 u: p8 R9 M# S; F0 ^6 b; T1 h
Darcy Paquet       四颗星
( K( O8 r. R$ b, W9 P. q# ]. d9 V$ d3 H
Ryoo Seung-beom's acting elevates the film from good to great.
3 T! N; l: ?, L; C1 mHurts so good. * r- r+ s; A: \; j8 `
Gives the boxing film genre a punch in the ribs.
9 O5 o% g  \3 w; ^4 G5 e: x
; Q. N: l7 O+ r/ q   
; V5 K- d0 |" A( iFeathers in the Wind (Git)   (风之羽)
0 G# `4 `% I! H+ `- s" k7 b   
" e3 W6 C! j; h4 }" |Paolo Bertolin 三颗半星
* h6 D7 z: X6 v( [* a5 T/ S3 EDavide Cazzaro  四颗星
) i" k! @8 s6 f  q# U1 wTom Giammarco  四颗半星 9 `& a8 u! o! a! L) ~1 }$ k. a, T  ]
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星! z& M- `! A4 a
Mark Russell  三颗星$ ?0 ~0 ?/ M$ O0 ^
1 v) A  c) v; f: @
Light as a feather, a small film often touched by grace.
6 W0 d" y3 W! g: K3 Q" ?Definitely one of the best Korean films produced in 2004. 9 c# A& c  ?" ]$ m6 S( K( ^+ ~: I
Beautiful images, expertly paced story and interesting characters
9 A8 ]. `+ h0 q$ o4 eKorea's most exciting screen romance in a very long time.
2 ~3 t: f- r! }* l" ?" INice little film, but nothing special.
6 X$ B$ H( x5 {7 h
" U5 t1 e& S- j8 P, w* S9 L0 R0 ~Green Chair   (绿椅子)
1 d. g9 A/ a$ K$ E/ ~. L   + F$ ]8 v' H* ?4 A1 M& `
Paolo Bertolin 四颗星
" a& H1 u1 m5 T7 a* H5 [0 oDavide Cazzaro  三颗星
& W  B! e7 K" B! O/ rFilmbrain   三颗星" ~3 X! r" F5 i  r/ B8 E  }( R
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星3 r% r  g9 ]  z" l- j! I+ I
Adam Hartzell 三颗星
( K6 P0 N) H- a0 ~0 U8 m* g% ADarcy Paquet  四颗星
" D9 {. d. ?9 s- T8 M% J0 s5 K: t; G$ G4 v3 D7 X( O0 X8 ?# Y# [( M

$ P$ N0 U! O. B' h3 B3 D+ D Asks the right questions in the proper manner. Heart-warming sex.
: \6 t( i( a: S0 v) sGood development of the story and fresh ideas. A little long.
1 @! D) E8 q, W( ^" z$ I4 Y/ RDaring, unconventional, sexy, and full of unexpected pleasures.
0 F4 p) k! L- E7 `7 {" |This would have been much better as a short film. Last 20 mins good.
" Z8 R3 t% v' d Park peeps behind the Green Chair and finds more Park particulars. 7 P* x! X* c% W* s, Y
Irreverent and obnoxious, but still very touching. 2 b" f) R5 D! p2 X
8 Y  ]/ k  V5 C0 R8 |
    3 d' A! L7 _. ^; A5 l4 i. `7 O
If You Were Me 2   (如果你是我 2 )5 I8 b% Z' k7 |
   ) }3 h2 w0 ^' B& b3 Q' f0 W( U" s5 ^
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星* j( Q7 `+ p  u' R
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星
! S; {1 T5 A/ N$ ^& ?1 g- a$ U- v4 p8 r
Arguably better than the original. Tightly focused storytelling.
7 _  _8 h/ s; YA well-formed omnibus (which is rare). Jung Ji-woo's is my favorite. & a6 U3 k, h2 S0 `0 c
5 }3 ?' k( }+ N% E

& |; j- D+ [4 b  e5 E. K7 Q9 o    8 D" B/ w% J: T5 ~5 C" w
Innocent Steps   ( 舞女纯情)
$ w) w' q4 X1 r- h   
: M3 ]% c: h8 w! ~$ RTom Giammarco  两颗半星1 X8 d& D1 r% `1 Y! b; W% _) r
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星$ q. G1 R3 q* p) j% a' j3 p  z- h
0 o7 Y, \0 ?) S. S
Disappointing and cliche.
( u% Q2 r. T- vI wish the screenwriter had just let them dance.
  c0 Q& b. f, z
3 u1 Z0 g* a! Q4 A' C- a% D( |
' o  x1 `" ?' z+ ]
' ^  J: j0 n0 }( j% H5 a8 `! AJenny, Juno   
+ I2 j( B0 I+ O7 D) J4 {" D2 x- v% ?1 D   
& v0 u2 D9 h' o+ F! J0 t! M0 xTom Giammarco  一颗星
( u8 h' t) D; K% H. z9 s2 uKyu Hyun  Kim  一颗半星2 T! ]8 L: @! l7 r6 L
Elif Kaya  两颗半星3 ^+ N$ D; B0 r  |! L
Darcy Paquet  两颗星9 w9 K" J4 G# s* U
  i& w3 ]% T5 P2 t5 R
Treats the subject of early-teen pregnancy much too lightly.
$ L" @) I7 a0 p' B0 ^9 w. i5 [Good Lord. Makes Blue Lagoon look like Umbrellas of Cherbourg . ; s- T& F4 O+ P0 `0 N
Stylish, feel good film, not much else is there though. ! D1 R- |, \; O1 H
I was enjoying this movie, and then I started to hate it.
+ ~$ P* Z+ W0 }( B* V4 p& W& S2 Y" I- R- T! i2 Y4 V
   
) Q/ H* g2 x- R& W1 d# kMapado   (麻婆岛). f) q( R9 R+ D0 p8 @
   
' n  p& W- S& l" n+ H+ nPaolo Bertolin 两颗星, z: R: v! q: y8 V
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星4 R0 ~! U. E+ [4 f8 j. V+ z9 X& [

1 a( A) ^. Q$ |, O& ~9 QFormulaic characters and contrived plot. Obnoxious and trivial. * j: h/ q  q0 x; {
Need to turn off your brain to get through this comedy. 4 a3 z; S" e; ?8 F) n, W
6 {7 ^+ P! L" ^% [) q4 q* u
   
  n7 @# V/ X2 D: t" cMarathon   (马拉松)0 x4 P6 t5 j# _) D8 L
   
( b) T$ s7 R8 B; U! n! `* @+ a. d; gPaolo Bertolin  一颗半0 N) f# r. v' S& l( T+ j
Tom Giammarco  四颗半
2 `, j0 _$ ^5 ]9 Y9 Y2 j0 q  @) M0 r6 H% p2 t2 p
Typical Korean woman-basher: it's all mum's fault! Cho overdoes it.
3 u" C* b  t! t$ a' rExcellent performances shine in this touching story.
. ~' i4 e" Q4 c/ Z' J, `- m
. n+ s3 v8 n+ u2 a- @
' ]& b. \+ b0 K2 OMy Boyfriend is Type-B   (我的B型男友)- V2 W2 P: \/ |6 l; _; K1 k( t
   
; ?: k# D! X; z5 e' M, |5 h  V0 v+ hTom Giammarco  . 两颗星% k3 U2 m, n  b! P; F8 w5 b3 \( F! l
Elif Kaya   两颗星, M, R6 k) f# G6 F; S
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
2 O) `& k3 p  K) J0 |, G    9 n) m4 }) ?, Q& h" @0 s  _" G6 w
Couldn't stand the characters. No chemistry between the leads) U. m; G: I% }- g1 J
Lacklustre rom com, only if you like any of the lead actors.
9 ?5 l( ^* z$ SHow about that Lotte product placement? * q7 j) e& H8 M/ p

5 v; L3 V/ S) ~( q: C# g0 ~+ IPossible Changes   (可能的变化)# M; r( t2 S& q% ~! f* P1 H; o
   # k& [4 P- u& |
Davide Cazzaro 一颗星
/ t( k3 l# R) Q* t, YTom Giammarco  一颗星- O) B) g. X- E0 ^; v
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
" s" c1 }/ v6 _, s: e2 i! R" b  Z  r3 N4 n
Former assistant to Hong Sang-soo tried to make a Hong film.
! w( W" V/ [7 |. [; K- i% vSomber, depressing, stagnant and pointless.
" o5 k9 z) _. x" WMaybe I missed something. I don't think so.
/ G* `. ^  S1 g7 @+ P7 w4 p7 }7 ?( s1 T
8 R& h& D: I0 q( R# X$ j& Y' }3 X
' A$ p! n5 ^# g0 E' c2 d
& F' g9 n3 _" `, O% B* ?. Y1 t, {
The President's Last Bang   (那时代,那些人), q  B5 G( |2 y$ ~6 `# z
   
" G9 w2 O. [3 N0 nPaolo Bertolin  三颗半星
/ }* ]4 q; h5 q; @* P% }James Brown  三颗半星
- z# g1 k# v/ ]( z7 o" ?6 `Davide Cazzaro  四颗半星8 b3 Y$ T3 j4 _
Filmbrain 四颗半星
' Q; R4 E" }) O) U% K7 fDarcy Paquet  四颗半星: z% t6 ?- `, F! a5 z/ Y) A& I- R
Mark Russell  四颗星. z. I7 |& @! L7 _: B
Boris Trbic  三颗半星) w, s6 w( K$ x' A+ O

, t) V7 M4 a+ E; g4 H; dIm knows how to dare, and his ambition and bravery deserve praise.
* ], Y* M2 d0 H4 o& _1 jHip, intrepid piece but its irreverence is just a touch too zealous.
, u6 q3 G7 b7 B- z; G- oWitty, provocative and mordent. A "must not miss" Korean film. ; h9 J1 F9 X9 T$ U- S: Q# @- L
Brilliant political satire that easily ranks with the best.
8 q" n: M3 f# `8 [Baek Yoon-shik is a god, and Im Sang-soo is a master.
( J1 a/ E; Z# g/ IMaybe not great history, but a great film. Dark and funny.
9 G. B% q( J  S% V* J/ H- JUndressing fascism can be fun. Gloomy and entertaining.  
7 W. {; ]1 G. e* }2 u* I
! m" {2 q. `8 X/ |5 }; ^   
: s& K7 K/ @) z8 |% c* \3 ZRed Eye   (红眼)
/ E: U$ ^2 h6 v   
7 s* g, z" M3 G+ M# f" E1 ?: z$ ZTom Giammarco  两颗星$ r# O( \8 p# m: v; m. E
Kyu Hyun  Kim  两颗半星
- C( \! F3 T- ]# d: Q6 zDarcy Paquet  一颗半星6 s' G9 t9 d. [  K$ Z
, q1 O, [2 s' g  P$ K' C4 Z. j
An embarrassment to ghosts everywhere.
* K! i# ~/ K) d7 iNo Oriental Express, but I rather fancied the train setting.
3 E8 i0 l7 m" N- {! XNice cast, but none of the emotions in the film hit home.
; T% U7 ?( a! n7 \# L2 U: x
1 }+ M0 M8 F# J1 Z   
. V1 |( B3 i! }! |7 @& jThe Red Shoes   (红鞋)$ r$ \  @9 \7 g0 t8 Y0 p9 _
   9 H. N! y3 b1 a
Tom Giammarco  三颗半星
, s. ~: C; j) w) y  I# qKyu Hyun  Kim  三颗星
4 Y+ b. Y# f% {3 a5 h+ D/ `6 v9 nDarcy Paquet  两颗半星2 R$ k* U0 A7 L
) x$ |7 B4 ~6 A# l9 Q
Kim Hye-su is excellent/Plot has many holes but manages to scare.
& J1 n+ N, M* H( N& }& fThe shoes are, uh, pink. At least Kim Hye-su dances to her tune. # ]4 r& }5 C: n2 D. F, h8 l
An A for style, a C- for enlightened creativity. 5 I5 L4 i: K! Y. m2 o# v  M

0 C: `5 O( u6 X$ c! m& [+ ^/ U; e- V- g. \0 J, W. y1 V# D
Road   (公路)
  ~2 P. R5 n8 h. @  w   9 i; P" h& T$ X2 L( p
Davide Cazzaro  三颗星, @' v% U/ y) r$ _0 B
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星, d4 y# z6 O' R6 |! h6 O
Darcy Paquet  三颗星
  h9 ]# K, h$ w' {$ c& |8 n8 _. }* U+ E& f+ _% o2 V+ |" o
Nothing very new but Bae Chang-ho shows his talent and experience.! o- Z+ ?# B  L9 L9 ^2 d% N
Great cinematography & story. Not perfect due to lead actress. 4 }8 T* @* b7 j% e, X6 W
Its slow-building emotional power is its greatest strength.
! c* H9 L9 W9 a' _9 l) p0 o& H9 ]$ z' l
0 m% p" G( z* I" `% h

3 O  g8 n5 G9 Z* O$ b# [Spying Cam   
. l) B2 o5 j* n0 j! s7 \+ A   
4 a& H' A- ?+ I5 |7 w$ m$ R( dPaolo Bertolin  四颗星- ]$ `! S: ^* l2 ?# V; r/ W* W
Darcy Paquet  两颗半星- e! u# H6 _+ E7 K" ]
! `. u5 ~7 t7 h& ]* \
Korean political background, yet universal ethics in a great film.
1 J4 w  H% |8 d- R& [4 H; ^Made with passion but not quite as much precision. ! v, _  B; @5 x  {0 w, g8 x" I

  [) u6 [9 Q/ y* `/ v$ _; L6 h
3 A$ z1 k0 L6 @   
; M% i- Y6 s( U' FTale of Cinema   (剧场前)- O5 R4 M, _# _! k6 ], ]
   9 k1 _' F& n0 j7 X5 V
Paolo Bertolin 两颗星1 B, U4 W6 I' `/ y9 x
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星. t- d) E0 B/ J, [; }, R  ~5 q; p
Mark Russell  两颗星
9 r2 j5 [. N( q- W/ S2 S" w' j3 ]6 l, f* H/ o% O2 G- e
An utter disappointment. Is Hong running out of inspiration? & s4 I- [# T* t7 a$ M9 x! `
Do I detect a tiny glimpse of optimism in this film? % G. S, _, L' O- b+ U# ^4 h
..ooOOoo....ooOOoo... Love that zoom. Dull and uninspired. 1 }3 ^& m! |& T2 R: n

3 w' g" H) q1 ?, M3 D3 z. E% s# h* u3 O1 n

- q  T) M8 Z1 j( e3 I- x$ \( }   
6 }: a/ Q6 v# |0 [, q. F' K# KThis Charming Girl   (女子晴惠). ]; l5 x1 |( L& [
   
4 c6 l% t1 g, ?2 {: Y) d5 t. v$ d3 u7 qDavide Cazzaro  四颗星/ T$ f2 D+ w3 ^- ]) j9 X. J9 {& A9 x* A
Filmbrain  三颗半星. k( G* W) Q- S( ^. U
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星
* ^0 Q! |8 S& f; m( K: B9 {Adrien Gombeaud  五颗星
0 r# [3 y( h. M5 b: t+ sAdam Hartzell  三颗半星# h* W1 q% r$ ~* P8 t
Kyu Hyun  Kim  四颗星8 z+ m  t, J3 P! O- f8 U$ A
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星
) s- u, g& _+ }; x' X( K* W6 ]+ e7 n, L  M: f
Probably the best debut of 2004. Let's keep an eye on Lee Yoon-ki.
  U/ Z0 _% M; v4 T/ DSmall, quiet, subtle. The kind of film we need to see more of.
( Z* Y8 u) H. w) IAmazing film giving intricate details of the life of one woman. $ O, w! M- j: z% F
She walks in beauty. & H/ w; V# a1 H0 w; X4 e
Not a jumped-up postal girl, but an intriguing character study.
/ Y- ^3 b* W( u# k- jFinally, a filmic antidote to the "YOU WANNA DIE?" Sassy Girls.
# E' I6 m: @. n! I) m3 {A quiet but strong film. Kim Ji-soo is worth following2 L  j; n8 t& n4 h0 L
6 I. j! P; y7 h% j! {. H
[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2005-8-6 at 10:37 ]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-6 07:54 | 显示全部楼层

包括了很多2005年以来放映的韩片,好像截止到六月份

以上只是KOREANFILM.ORG这个网站中的人员的一些投票,他们的口味偏专家一些,也许和一般的观众有点点不一样.即便里面的人,有时候针对一部电影,也会有截然不同的结果.
0 B; F! B; r# J. Q; F$ s0 G" N7 @3 I. x/ g2 ~9 N
看了这么多,感觉好像到2005年的六月份为止,在超过一百万人次的电影中,<那时代,那些人>获得这些影评人的很高的评价,<甜蜜人生>和<哭泣的拳头>也是评价也很不错的,小众电影中,<女子晴惠>,<风之羽><绿椅子>等也是评价非常不错.<南极日记>比较惨,是输了票房,又输了影评的那种两头不落好的电影(成功的商业电影也不是好做的),<公共之敌2>,<麻婆岛>至少还有票房在,<马拉松>好象评价很极端,个人认为还是艺术质量还不错的大众片.金基德和洪尚秀今年的作品似乎并不被这些影评人欣赏.
3 m1 X7 P7 W9 p( ^0 A3 S" Y6 |1 W, c0 P, x
[ Last edited by lwang on 2005-8-6 at 08:03 ]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
发表于 2005-8-6 11:24 | 显示全部楼层
目前截止,,<那时代,那些人>的确是上半年的翘楚之作!!
# q+ X  O1 E; o1 i/ t9 G& q他们对<哭泣的拳头>评价不错,但个人感觉真是一般啊!!柳没什么特色!
此时无声胜有声

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-7 10:28 | 显示全部楼层
<亲切的金子>也许会是下半年最重要的作品了. 就目前所知道的这些有名的导演的作品来看,也就这部值得看了.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

联系我们|手机版|小黑屋|韩剧社区 ( 蜀ICP备14001718号 )

JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!

GMT+8, 2025-4-10 10:00 , Processed in 0.187856 second(s), 22 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.5

© 2001-2025 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表