找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 1852|回复: 11

【心中韩影】《into the mirror》--镜中疑云

[复制链接]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
发表于 2003-12-1 20:53 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
偶今天中午刚看完的,很后悔没有在午夜看…4 M7 J: j- r" h0 S0 A3 M
惊喜的发现,这是继《蔷花,红莲》后,另一种类型的
/ D2 H7 h- w" y7 ]经典!!刘智泰所挑的剧本,一向都粉有水准!
4 W3 p7 `+ W' q' t5 X5 D( L3 w/ ~3 O5 L  y& I2 S' P
不俗的侦探灵异片,且不乏哲理味,其中关于镜子的  t2 e: }5 u3 {' V
许多台词,细细揣摩,让人浮想联翩。。。  ~8 r8 p: `  u- G- k- v

7 I5 x: g& S+ G; y除了那个精神受创的警察Young-min,本片的另一位非3 P" x, L) F5 P7 y( Z/ x. [
常重要的主角,就是“镜子”,它是串起一切的线索,也
9 f* m' E. l. x* J% O1 [是本片的灵魂。导演并无耍弄任何毫无价值的装神弄鬼,
6 s5 M* C4 \/ e' O0 c片中的鬼魂也并不可怕,因为它的所作所为合情合理。倒
; C* ~) g+ B, n/ \3 w7 I9 E- q是镜子,才会真正唤起你内心的恐惧。Young-min的遭9 \* H# [9 Z, t+ M; t5 |6 l* q
遇因镜子而起,最后的归宿当然也跟镜子有关。片中每
0 k; ^! {! b6 \) W  b% _5 Y7 z) U逢镜子出场,你原本紧绷的神经线便会为之一颤…..
5 F( @; j8 [7 z  c; a  Y4 x/ _; h
7 A: m0 c! N5 I( v. q) E镜子里的世界,原来另有乾坤,那是一个与客观完全相. j; v6 f. v, v# d9 x) \
反的 世界。透过镜子,我们可以看到一个相反的自己,  h! ]( o3 c4 E
但那不过是“虚像”,你所见到的,不等于一切。又或& ]& e; c# w$ Y8 r; O
许,我们都是双面人,一个是外在的我,一个是心里的
0 o+ g; h% k( m5 z我。所谓的“战胜自我”,就是战胜心里的我?当心里
4 b6 K& B: c' [3 T" f# k$ h' l的我退出战场,结果,又会怎样?
1 U7 q5 f9 A1 h6 a7 q. s& ]! C$ q# T+ h3 D6 ?0 s
本片的结局,由于前面的种种铺陈而十分合理,但绝对
6 j' e$ m+ [- M- n* P; ^+ x  s6 n会出乎你的意料之外!!你本以为一切又归复平静,但4 a. w. \4 t- ]
其实高潮的到来即是结尾的收场,导演直到最后一刻才
' ~1 g% X) I, n' ~7 L* @: d道出了影片真正的重点,一锤定音,让人心悸的余音缭, r+ W: j+ j( o' {8 m. s
绕…….9 k9 U7 s  S8 [% L

, L2 C. @( ^! w* `% o: Y[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2005-5-30 at 11:24 AM ]
此时无声胜有声

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2003-12-1 21:00 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by lalanono at 2003-12-1 08:57 PM:
4 Q* z' [& ?" T+ k
$ _' B6 f' A# B! ]/ v# j/ Y应该把他归类到恐怖片灵异片还是侦破呢??
1 j" C6 s7 L7 P. z( e
应该是灵异+侦破+推理+哲理!
此时无声胜有声

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2003-12-1 21:23 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by lalanono at 2003-12-1 09:18 PM:
4 r2 b; g, C0 }是原声吧!!那找来看看!!飞马会出吗?出的话看看是不是收藏!9 r. P+ _2 G$ P# m% u3 m
谢谢阿韩提供的信息!!

5 B* _* Q& ], d+ G0 F当然是原声,音效很好,只是图像有点不清,但请放心介个不是影版的,租来看看倒也划算!
- i$ b; B1 G+ x0 I1 `( H+ ?飞马一定会出的啦,偶是还没看到,说不定已经有了~
此时无声胜有声

59

主题

3637

回帖

5701

积分

★VIP會員★

归去来兮 醉红尘

积分
5701
发表于 2003-12-1 22:05 | 显示全部楼层
影片扣题精准, 把镜子的文章做足了, 主人公在镜子中背负朋友死亡的痛苦, 更因镜子中的一系列死亡而将悬疑气氛酝酿得扣人心弦. 镜子中的你, 是你, 非你? 死去的还是活着的, 让人思索. " [/ n" z+ ~: V" u3 H
最后的画面, 看不到镜子中自我的主人公, 是活下来的是另一个自我, 挑战过去而成功的镜子中的人?
0 O) P0 i# Z- Y5 x* s: I这部影片值得一看. 但最后杀人凶手的现形让这种灵异的气氛削弱了, 镜子中的鬼魅这么了得, 为什么不去直接杀死仇人, 而等到主人公最后的出场,  导演布下的阵局,  不禁让人觉得有些故弄玄虚了.....

3

主题

913

回帖

1965

积分

白金长老

积分
1965
发表于 2003-12-2 01:15 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by 小王子 at 2003-12-1 11:09 PM:
6 c! O) E. V7 h是春逝里的那个人吗

( G. x0 o+ J( g2 B1 E- ]2 ~; [, J4 U3 M0 }2 A
6 e5 B+ K' f# ?1 B$ |
就是演尚优的刘志太
4 m. I3 Z- I! I2 m0 \' c( _
6 K; I' h* H: w' M纯支持一下
; I6 R# k" v" q. Q3 l不过觉得这类惊悚片也不算太新鲜
) E. N6 B5 J2 s; S, U但是不敢看
  h+ n3 C, K  S9 ?呵呵~3 [3 r  X+ T  h% }* R1 A. z) T
( P  r6 K* V' i" [) u* q& Q
现在是很期待志太和崔民植的《old boy》哎~

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2003-12-2 11:40 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by 阳阳 at 2003-12-1 10:05 PM:
) ?( D. e! [3 m- {! M  ~  A( _$ n镜子中的鬼魅这么了得, 为什么不去直接杀死仇人, 而等到主人公最后的出场,  导演布下的阵局,  不禁让人觉得有些故弄玄虚了

4 \8 q( g3 Z" k* x! I) w) F( g& X*spoil alert** o+ V9 U0 P! F& t
1 c) k. M7 f% |* v5 Y7 L( R* [. F

0 o; N9 O+ H6 [" P' v% K" i9 b. R' O! P
& B" X! S4 ~- B3 X6 P$ m; b9 O9 n
+ \8 s9 K$ e4 l, W! v# _! T7 ?/ z3 q# V

+ a0 ]. F9 `* q. S5 O: X4 T! E5 D! h* E9 e( N. J4 S& k, y' D
+ n5 e" `2 ?: ^6 d0 E* u; |% L
& d3 q( V" V0 A5 V6 ]
9 n( q  w; a; [+ ]
呵呵,偶当时也有想到这个问题,但后来为它找了个自圆其说的解释:它不只想报仇这么简单,其最终目的还是想揭开阴谋的真相,而它本身无法做到这点,因为它只附属于镜子。所以它必须依靠一个人来帮它达到目的,这个人就是Young-min.
此时无声胜有声

20

主题

1402

回帖

2778

积分

白金长老

积分
2778
发表于 2003-12-2 14:23 | 显示全部楼层
聽了阿韓幾句簡單的論述,對這部片子的興趣感大增,很想了解當他在排迴、恐慌、不知如何時,是否會把鏡子當作自已的另個附屬品看待,從之前的因果循環利用鏡子得到另個假像中的真相,應該是部值得探討的影片,我像這部片子的水準恐怕會是在鬼魅之上了!

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2003-12-2 15:30 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by katebeckinsale at 2003-12-2 02:23 PM:
' o" W% J1 W. L; V我像這部片子的水準恐怕會是在鬼魅之上了
2 X/ e4 w, s. q
其实两者风格大不相同,各有千秋吧!如果要比的话,偶觉得《into the mirror》更理性些,而《鬼魅》则是感性的!) ~( H: f3 o  ]: z" T# M# `
要论内涵,《into the mirror》的确更胜一筹,它有值得探讨的深度,且是一部真正的“灵异”片!《鬼魅》的重点则不在“灵异”上,它也没什么深度,仅仅是只一个“故事”而已。一个古老僵化的传说,导演对它进行现代修正,想传递的是一种美丽哀愁的感觉和“花香梳骨的寒意”(quote桌紫)!它的古典华丽和丰富的细节使它具备反复观赏的价值。而《into the mirror》这种侦探片则是看一遍已足够回味的了!
此时无声胜有声

59

主题

3637

回帖

5701

积分

★VIP會員★

归去来兮 醉红尘

积分
5701
发表于 2003-12-2 19:07 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by 阿韩 at 2003-12-2 11:40 AM:
! V- i6 y& c2 b, {% C+ `* e8 s呵呵,偶当时也有想到这个问题,但后来为它找了个自圆其说的解释:它不只想报仇这么简单,其最终目的还是想揭开阴谋的真相,而它本身无法做到这点,因为它 ...
+ D7 J4 [8 P4 o- p2 j

) H% z+ ~8 @7 t7 L+ {  A5 D# d7 D阿韩说得有道理~  看来鬼魅也是要洗清自己的冤屈, 让恶人得到应有的惩罚.
% G0 ]* B; u$ \& }* p$ s% U, u我更愿意把这部片子看做是灵异片, 杀人的过程很玄妙,  导演也用了不少的镜头来表现鬼魅的离奇. 最后的包袱倒显得无足轻重了, 不过最后能解脱主人公于梦魇般的过去, 把镜子的意味挖掘得更深, 不失为一部用心良多的影片.
, x& U% I$ h) g$ |# h6 u# o  i9 p& C5 z& U  K8 l5 V
[ Last edited by 阳阳 on 2003-12-2 at 07:10 PM ]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2003-12-2 20:42 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by 吹雪 at 2003-12-2 08:32 PM:
( e  A2 o  d6 F, i8 Q! I" J  S+ }我还看见有卖他的另一部恐怖片<凶咒>,有人看过吗?

& W1 V, j# F. a& O* K2 v早期的韩恐片,千万别看!!!这好象是智泰参演的首部电影,也是最烂的一部!从之后他所选的剧本中,可以看出他的成长迅速!
此时无声胜有声

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
 楼主| 发表于 2004-3-1 18:59 | 显示全部楼层
Originally posted by wwyyjj200 at 2004-1-28 06:26 PM:
# l3 @; \6 G1 v5 r0 L$ R1 V看来阿韩要移情别恋了
# Y# L' y! u. Z, Y
移情是指。。。' u) g/ O! H: P/ K6 {) f" S
如果是指鬼魅(蔷花红莲),那是不可能滴,它是偶最钟爱的电影,偶是永远的蔷花嬖人!! o1 B, C2 o/ @, r
偶前面也说过了,蔷花红莲具备反复观赏的价值。而into the mirror,叫偶看第二遍的话,偶会觉得没意思~
) T; R6 T7 a$ h% ^' \: {( a* G2 x  B% i! D% F) f
--------------------------------------------------------------------
9 E6 o5 _+ V- H2 X+ W1 M+ b0 J& d5 J( D% x8 g. b$ Y: V
by wwyyjj200:5 M& q& Y4 D' h) ~6 m
# S4 ]; S/ w! J- h* n+ I3 Y) |
阿韩说的对,《蔷花红莲》的确是能够让人反复回味的片子。我就是看了它才喜欢上韩国电影的。自那以后买了十几张碟,竟没有一部能象《蔷花红莲》一样给我以震撼的,也许这就是曾经沧海难为水吧。7 G, Y$ D4 W8 y- n
顺便问一句,下面这幅图片是在《蔷花红莲》的什么地方,我怎么找遍了整个电影也没找到这个场景?
+ T( o4 M7 D, v) M' }- D

$ V! Y; Y) }- A+ J3 c                               
登录/注册后可看大图

0 k& t  ^+ C- s0 I* ~: H* E8 {------------------------------------------------------------------------# c% s& S" K# k9 c
: u' J* A( z  i9 x- k4 V
Originally posted by wwyyjj200 at 2004-1-31 01:21 AM:
* d% G1 D- W; I% N阿韩说的对,《蔷花红莲》的确是能够让人反复回味的片子。我就是看了它才喜欢上韩国电影的。自那以后买了十几张碟,竟没有一部能象《蔷花红莲》一样给我以震撼的,也许这就是曾经沧海难为水吧。
2 @9 l: d) m3 X5 q8 a! k3 E* |顺便问一句,下面 ...
% D4 m7 L5 c' U- ]3 t& ~5 _' v0 T
wwyyjj200~~来~握手~拥抱!1 q9 [$ e$ R& t. }$ y. ~2 \6 }' `' K
别怪偶太热情,所有喜欢《蔷花红莲》的人,偶都想跟她来个大大滴拥抱嘿嘿
% [* X8 r% ~( a+ ^* \! }  q" _对于这部电影,偶真有知音恨少的感觉,懂它的人少,喜欢它的人更少,而像偶这样狂热的影迷,在国内大概是绝无仅有了吧?:P+ K& l) V9 [8 k0 y  t
& O- q( t4 L; w' o  U8 M- N
那张图不是剧中的场景,只是宣传剧照
; v9 Q( q0 q" F8 A" W这里有更多:http://www.krdrama.com/bbs/viewt ... =%C1%D6%D0%E3%BE%A7
. U1 o) f% f! V/ E: J7 V, J6 K# v: H+ p% ]2 i
--------------------------------------------------------------------------7 ^  a- Q* f) T8 D5 t1 O
( ], v$ `6 E% g# y/ ?2 F
Originally posted by kittymimi at 2004-1-31 10:09 AM:. Z9 O+ n, M  V; R2 u# p
好高兴阿韩也说刘智泰选片的眼光有水准,他的OLD BOY和自然城市我同样期待。
5 ?9 f4 P; {% s% n6 s" ]' V! V
《old boy》偶一直好想看啊!!!至于《自然城市》,虽然票房不理想,评价也不一,但偶照样有所期待!9 Q) L0 ]/ z7 ]5 [
————& ~+ P" U. s0 U, J! R
mjcampagna
8 N) l3 J/ _" h, Z4 RMember since Feb-4-03
; ^1 X( A6 u/ m" S) P! {8 E Jan-20-04, 02:15 AM (Seoul Time)
/ ?& y) a6 i* j3 X( f   6 m1 a8 d4 B! E) H. j- f& M
"Natural City - Review"
3 Z4 r$ y  [$ p( u
. r. q. Y6 ~; }+ }* }% V   I watched Natural City today. The short of it is that it's a film worth watching once, if you're into sci-fi. Anyone else will probably want to skip it, and I'd advise a rental before a purchase.( p. R! O: ~% i  r% J$ G/ p
The long of it goes something like this:
/ V; U* l0 V; s- B! B, c8 j8 b; H
8 E/ t$ c: j. E1 |9 ZThis time wants very much to be Bladerunner. The cyberpunk atmosphere is in full effect, and it even has fly-by adverts for off-world colonies, a la Bladerunner. And the rogue cyborgs, a la Bladerunner. And the airborne "cars" flying over the city, a la Bladerunner.
" K. S2 |& P. s: h) G# _  ~2 A4 Q
The emotional center of the film revolves around an MP (similar in all ways to Bladerunner's Bladerunner units) whose job is to hunt down rogue cyborgs, but who is actually in love with a cyborg, Ria, who is near her expiration date. The plot follows his endeavors to circumnavigate that expiration and to live with her. Sounds awfully similar to certain aspects of another film I've seen, called . . . Bladerunner. Except, in Bladerunner, the cyborgs were attempting to reach that end on their own, and Harrison Ford fell in love with his cyborg in the course of the film, rather than being in love with her from the start.$ G8 _' P% Y& C% {' V
- }6 q6 A; n4 W3 w/ y& v7 f
The special effects are oddly imbalanced in the film. They are used to wonderful effect to create atmosphere. On the short end of the stick, however, we have the fight sequences, which are all very boring, poorly editted and which fail to differ in any significant way from one to the next. In addition, the "combat cyborgs" are easily the least impressive looking characters in the entire film. In their younger years, my little brother and his friends once made a ninja movie in our backyard, and the "combat cyborgs" in this film so very closely resemble my brother in their attire that I think they should be paying him royalties. You might think I'm exaggerating this point, but really, I'm not. They're really that bad. And aside from posing and flying around like mannequins, they really don't do much in the way of fighting. In fact, most of the fight scenes boil down to a few brief clips of the "combat cyborgs" flying around, jumping out of the water or grabbing MPs from the ceiling, and then the MPs all shoot each other in confusion.
6 M! }: s7 c; Q) F. _
+ f2 h3 [6 X* ]0 \In addition to the terrible fight scenes, the relationship between the two lead MP characters never really gets interesting either.) o5 C- @: ^$ c0 a3 P# R# @
+ B( f; [1 x# [+ |
To the film's credit, however, it does manage to create of very sad and sentimental relationship between Ria and the film's protagonist, R, in his quest to extend her life. You really can't help but feel sorry for them. I really felt sorry for them in a way.5 [0 e# {2 d% l( Y
. \  V2 j6 B/ C6 w: k( P# ?$ D
As for the character of Cyon, she's not very well developed and is used as little more than a plot device to tie the otherwise fragmented shreds of a story into one another. She is the unwitting connection between the film's love story and the diabolical conflict that forms the core of the film's poorly executed action.. ?( Z! E6 Q+ I, J) R
  Z: _! U" M# F- O* w0 _3 E9 g
In the end, this film is too much like Bladerunner for its own good, but not good enough to stand its ground against that film, now more than 20 years old. If you liked Bladerunner and need more of the same, then you might find this film interesting in ways. If you're a diehard sci-fi nut, then you should definately check this out.* m1 a4 q0 Q5 H1 }* I3 @
+ D7 w4 i; G( G( Z4 [
But most viewers will likely find little to like in this film. While it's not blatantly offensive to my sensibilities, it doesn't stroke them much, and in the end, I feel very neutral about the entire affair.
- G, w7 B) L3 B  V6 c5 l  X( L9 ~# Z9 N% n! p  }+ K
Natural City is decent for a one time viewing. I feel no need to own this film, however, for if I want to watch this sort of thing, I'll just pop my Bladerunner into the DVD instead and walk away from it without the mixed feelings that this film incites.0 ^1 Q9 L7 v/ E* Q" ]( w
* T7 B6 K+ `$ b% @6 x) ]8 Z
At times lovely and touching, and at times a half-baked imitation of a 20-year-old masterpiece of science fiction, Natural City brings nothing to the table that hasn't been seen before and ultimately fails to impress.2 y9 Z% k9 |7 }! }) J" b  \
" i( z: J" S" z8 v. v8 u! x; e
Korean film does a very nice job in many genres, but this film once again shows that sci-fi isn't one of them.  z" `; r8 `# O/ I/ E/ Y3 n
/ w5 [# p& f/ w  e

3 Z' A' {4 }7 [0 N# ^: E3 Y 5 U0 [* m4 r' R, m/ }
3 `  U/ M3 E: q% Q0 w% H
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~: y" j( |' j" |1 C( ?( r
4 n/ ~# M) W4 K
hwang
: D# y( x! {' n  K7 LMember since Jun-3-03+ p$ t6 _) O5 \4 B
Jan-20-04, 03:26 PM (Seoul Time) " o& N# E1 ^$ L0 R% g8 M/ f
     - P7 u' c, _' w
1. "RE: Natural City - Review"
. O3 B& b- {" Y' _: y  H0 n* _2 YIn response to message #0% b% W4 A0 Y) L
9 y5 u6 ?7 o4 f4 s. x- D% C
   I haven't seen Blade Runner, perhaps this is why I'm favorably disposed to NC.
# U$ N0 o& T+ [8 `9 s) N9 k# r' hI figure NC is a like it a lot or hate it movie. In that respect it reminds me of SORUM which is hardly scary but nevertheless interesting and rich with subtexual nuances and details. The way I respect Sorum, and even movies like Wonderful Days, is the same for how I respect Natural City. The narrative doesn't feel charged at all and so an audience member wishing to be pushed and pulled Hollywood style wouldn't feel fulfilled at all; but for an introspective guy like me the movie's ulterior richness, its psychological "offness," its overall wretched hopelessness in mood and the music, gives an impression that settles in a way that's appreciable. So, alhough not a great movie, NC is certainly not a stupid movie. I like it a lot.: Z; E8 q. c+ ^( B* Y) U: r! {9 J
+ k1 W9 [) B1 e  z) T% E, b
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~$ p9 y0 ]3 }4 i( |4 _
9 l. x5 ^# q/ V1 t! J2 q
mjcampagna 8 y3 L" L" a6 F- b8 D' e4 i
Member since Feb-4-03
. [) @* d+ L& }$ q8 K5 u Jan-20-04, 11:56 PM (Seoul Time) ( m  a: b) O+ q! Y( R) f
   7 m( a/ P' ~0 w+ c# G; k- V
2. "RE: Natural City - Review"+ V5 }2 C3 _2 E& _$ ?/ c
In response to message #1' R) ~( u: g$ X1 S" P' H5 s

# [0 p! A1 [# k& g   I never said that it was stupid; just disappointing and unoriginal. Wonderful Days I seriously disliked, and haven't seen Sorum. Natural City is definately better than Wonderful Days though, in my opinion.2 P; d! W4 R& X# F8 o
But seriously, if you like this sort of stuff, you should most definately check out Bladerunner. I'd go so far to say that it is the single best sci-fi film of the 80s (and probably better than anything from the 90s as well), and the special effects were way ahead of their time. The film holds its own against any modern film in terms of visuals, it has a great storyline and it's got a fantastic cast as well. It was based on the novel by Philip K. Dick (good book), who also wrote the stories upon which Minority Report and Paycheck were based. Bladerunner is easily the best of the films, though. Judging from what you say about the lack of Hollywood pulls and pushes, I think you would also find the pacing of the film quite to your liking.
  u7 A  V% ^2 o+ B6 i7 C, z  W" P: o; V  ]6 i/ k! H
And after you see Bladerunner, I'm sure you'll agree that NC uses it largely as source material. Or if you see it and disagree, I'd love to hear your thoughts on that as well. So, do check it out; I urge you. You won't be disappointed.
- y+ o1 D2 t# ?2 y. _5 s3 \  j* L7 X) H
So far, my favorite Korean sci-fi film has been 2009: Lost Memories. I really enjoyed some of the themes of cultural identity, and the way that it incorporated Korea's history into everything. It made it a distinctly Korean sci-fi film and really set it apart from most others, which tend to be fairly culturally ambiguous films. What did you think of that one hwang?6 R0 O6 i: B" B

! V4 R5 s  E7 i% |' S3 o; `+ g0 i9 P' I& z6 N

  [& s. Q! L/ {; t7 Z# B2 c~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
( ^# m$ r- }4 _/ K, {+ y
1 ]% x7 x% R' Q' u; ^$ C; t1 [johnny
" X. v# |. ^7 z/ t0 F. l, w/ xMember since Jan-25-032 B8 |% K# B, G
Jan-21-04, 02:15 AM (Seoul Time)   A: N: j/ Y' _7 c3 L4 ^0 P* E' z
     
+ H% z" q4 K1 z" m1 Y3. "RE: Natural City - Review"
' a- t& u1 w; f! qIn response to message #2
9 C# G+ J; y3 L7 ^0 j+ N1 ?
7 o/ r" y8 X7 A. K% y" ^6 Q7 L   I heard mixed reviews of this movie, but i'm going to buy it anyway.! G8 }, x1 q6 Q6 W$ A9 Q7 ?: ~
How's the movie compared to other sci-fi movies like 2009 and Yesterday, i saw that "mjcampagna" liked 2009 more than Natural City.: y3 R: v& T$ f0 w  v4 m4 d) R

8 M2 ?7 G, p8 R5 f% t7 W( w, z2 p) H
5 f# p3 y- R; _  i. V/ F~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- U. K$ H7 S9 b0 ]

8 v, R6 T. V2 _ jakechong
  J) j. c; _( [% |+ l, t* Z% dMember since Feb-14-034 ?: ^; b+ d7 M( g) v% _
Jan-21-04, 02:55 PM (Seoul Time)
( J% e7 C. y$ p     ) J! r  l& b5 N
4. "RE: Natural City - Review") n! [3 r) [# l9 T
In response to message #3
& r" X0 z. _) ?& q 7 ^, h+ J' N/ C! q. [+ b; O
   Natural City is definitely better than Yesterday...^^
$ U) o& @1 D" X; B
* v4 Y7 c; v9 K. ^
7 J  t- I+ Q! N6 ]+ A; ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  Z$ O1 _5 R0 f. Z

$ T! h* f& L- @' n4 t9 {( h" R/ ?% I( T$ ljohnny / J7 f- O6 S5 o. j6 s
Member since Jan-25-03
! j( K3 ~4 a  @/ L/ w! k( ] Jan-21-04, 08:14 PM (Seoul Time)
7 J/ n+ J, [7 n# G; o     
( z4 r0 K" c$ ?* Z' Z5. "RE: Natural City - Review"9 u2 D6 K& C# e+ C
In response to message #4
' ?9 p! @* E& H. e % g" S2 w) O1 f. b/ N1 t
   I've seen Yesterday and 2009 and i must say I enjoyed Yesterday more than 2009, Lost Memories had good actors and looked amazing but i think the hole movie got off the track.+ `! o, I3 l2 `/ _
Yesterday also looked very good, but the story was kind of hard to follow and i think something were missing.4 Z- A+ T& m' a3 {! ]6 T8 a
So out of this i think i'm going to like Natural City ) q$ P$ y: ^5 i; {5 x. E

; o# t! [5 S4 x- d+ i- b4 R5 g 6 Z  T# M& ^! `5 y+ M
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
2 ]- [  `0 S! Q- w+ A! g* p/ V7 C9 q- t0 J. @( k/ O7 j$ D
nkw88
  R' q) P: b! F7 e! b* Z# ZMember since Jan-26-02% P) i+ x* f+ r5 K3 ~% w
Jan-22-04, 05:29 AM (Seoul Time) 1 R. [/ y+ N+ l  V- r9 e& q
     
6 u3 P$ v% N; Z. H6 [4 ~6. "Blade Runner and Wolf Brigade"1 ^; F4 b7 T. \5 P( e7 W, \
In response to message #5
* _1 ~" F' [* C
- ~7 O' w& b* k8 z   LAST EDITED ON Jan-22-04 AT 01:23 PM (Seoul Time)
8 y. L* `1 l- o3 e0 m! e& E1 a ! |& D  y* ~# Y" X. t! h
In Blade Runner, though the main is Deckard, it is Roy who got 4 b/ F- J9 M& O+ U2 \7 X2 @! x
viewers' sympathy and whose motivation to prolong his life makes
% L  {1 p& w' d. k* j% A: bthe story proceed.% a5 X* w0 |8 ]1 h) @" T; K. Z
Anyway, the main axis is the struggle between Roy and Deckard.9 B0 p$ a4 ]/ u: q/ o6 w- Z* l( `" x
But, in Natural City, the main motivation of R is to prolong Rea's life.
+ E" r1 P* C6 L; W  c) u4 iThis is rather sentimental and tragedic than myterious mood.
. D: L9 p% g2 E& s2 k( bThe failure of this film is the failure of characterization.
' o, J* o' i" M; xDespite the loss of Rea, R does not look despearate.: e! b2 H1 c0 J
The evil character, Cyper, is not convincing.
1 j% B4 s) G+ S1 X
( a( L& ]/ O5 JThe image of MP, the armored police unit who executes genetic mutants,
* h# g/ q. g8 \is rather similar to OSHII Mamoru's Wolf Brigade or Kerberos than
4 }" s" \1 z& f* {3 jBlade Runner. % |; G# v, U7 ]& f, t0 k0 H

  i% n, X' T* [) y8 x' f5 wThe image of slum area is similar to HONG KONG in GHOST IN THE SHELL.
- J( {0 {# k+ E6 [0 T: p9 X) NEven some signs in computer and singboard are Chinese characters.
* {" _7 y! |, M: CConsidering Korean young generation does not know Chinese character, 8 N8 q0 m: a: X: M5 [! d- x, L9 m
the director does not need to use Chinese Character.
+ B  G) n  j8 x, A% a5 I" \
3 S4 r5 C4 j- l! MMany goog Sci-Fi films are adaptation of good Sci-Fi novels.
# G- v4 @8 o4 n  dThe failure, or weakness, of Korean Sci-Fi films is related to
$ e7 T/ {  r( c! y- V+ `the fact that there is no good Sci-Fi novel or no tradition of 0 z3 `9 P+ L. H  G
sci-fi literature. That's why this film looks like Japanese or
# c1 c5 Z0 h% v2 }depending Hollywood films., ^8 q; T( d: D0 m6 I

$ a. x  U! |1 ^% x" uBUT it was nice try and its achievement is greater than Resurrection
8 K0 J- L* P; Z- `. lof Little Match Girl. At least, Natural City, 2009 Lost Memories, and. D+ r2 i7 [5 T6 B1 L. Q; X: y- l
Yesterday look like big budget film.
0 X6 o; Q# V; W% ~8 iI expect more deveoped sci-fi film.' e% ?; B9 i9 K+ |' ^( H

8 L4 b8 Z2 X* _( |$ a: e3 I9 p2 A8 |3 U) ~4 q' p7 `
5 {+ i/ @' `: p# @% Z7 u$ f0 `
2 ?+ h- R; \" X1 Q0 d  M
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
( ~% z, b* {' t7 [4 o) f, I
$ r6 t4 ~, [5 P5 i. _Nicole
" L' f* T2 S2 f$ fMember since Jan-21-04
) n. n4 r2 z3 y6 }# b Jan-22-04, 02:16 PM (Seoul Time)
! X, U& H; j! n) s7 n* c2 y   
# I  l5 C1 X' M* t4 O7 a7. "The director's intention", `% o$ U. K) ~, ?7 N
In response to message #6
1 U. e* Z! f* L& G/ @: O  b 0 x- a% W/ }* j- m; N2 q" a  X$ ~
   I haven't received my order from Yesasia so haven't had chance to see Natural City yet. So I appreciate you guys reviews. I want to mention one thing though. I read the Korean movie magazine 'Screen' every month, and remember reading the director of Natural City's interview. He said he DELIBERATELY chose the settings to be very Japanese and Chinese in terms of the style because he wanted to warn us Koreans that this could really happen in the future if we didn't value our identities and accepted whatever that was foreign without any caution. Just want you guys to know that. I read Yu Ji Tae was quite depressed because the film wasn't well received by the public after all the hard works and high expectations and Choi Min Sik was the one who gave him a pat on his shoulder to console him. How nice Yu Ji Tae made up beautifully in Old Boy WITH Choi Miin Sik!
: [5 ?( G" \3 n  k+ j- O/ H
# q( ]  p# t/ W& U0 P , A$ R0 e0 x" m" _: l7 u
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~" i4 A$ o% a! X; S7 |) _1 B
# O0 N: d- A! b) I# J$ G
nkw88 ! |7 t! g. d& \# ]: f; A0 o$ U
Member since Jan-26-025 b7 n" W" D0 f* v8 o: z6 x
Jan-22-04, 02:49 PM (Seoul Time) 8 _( b, p# G0 i! e6 ~+ P
       y; ]: w& k+ @& a8 a$ }' O. p
8. "RE: The director's intention"
& O3 e) k' N& ^/ GIn response to message #74 a1 O/ a+ W9 b2 _7 Q# z* i
) w* T7 c9 e; S) P
   LAST EDITED ON Jan-23-04 AT 12:31 PM (Seoul Time)1 i$ y$ x2 S5 n( E8 v
4 j% v, N9 E! B. a
Hmm, director's intention is very interesting but it is hard to tell
1 `5 e8 _, ]8 G4 ?the warning from the influence. If he wants to warn us the loss of
! I7 G5 G' O+ X: g3 e5 tidentity, why doesn't he describe the slum area as Korean style# O; w- Q1 K' y2 K, H
residence rather than South East Asian style? He may want just to show) p" H& l; R, w- P/ b
that all Korean culture will be erased in 2080. ( l5 @! r( g3 ^, g6 A% H6 I& u3 a& _6 d
I am not wrong, there is no reference of what city it is.3 l% b; R8 [9 R4 e6 }
* Sorry, I am wrong. The statue of LEE Sun-Shin means that the city
4 p) A9 \6 Y" [5 }# Vis Seoul. Nevertheless, the image of the city is the compression of
% G" R# ~0 D) Z5 `+ mspace fo Asia, which was similar to the Chinese/Cambodian style
9 ~( _/ |  P: S4 W. b6 l/ K: r+ O' Lstreet of Blade Runner. However strong Japanese and Chinese influece6 X' T+ m& y7 r
may be, South East Asian slum in Seoul can be hardly explained.* i$ a  v0 h& k2 B5 T! B, t9 r1 b

, v8 A, e. `& }: v6 J1 c' B/ AMaybe the residence of immigrant workers can be related to this slum. n# G5 h. S/ y( ~2 M( _
and ruins. Then, is LEE Jae-Eun character an South East Asian?) p7 T1 H" O$ ~* L+ H% p$ K" `. F
fm:http://www.koreanfilm.org/htdocs/dcforum/DCForumID1/2175.html
4 ^0 @- ?$ ~* y' I$ X
, T& {+ P+ x# G3 H5 ?& N; n' e----------------------------------------------------------------------------------1 ^$ x7 g2 G. F3 A& C) v
7 G! D6 f/ Q9 L  z
by kittymimi:
, j$ ?) H% p+ A8 ~8 f2 f" @刘智泰的银幕处女作是98年和金荷娜的《再见,俊》,英文名叫《Bye June 》,是一部青春电影,描写一些刚满20岁,心情还不定的年轻人,在自己心目中宛如青春偶像的好友死亡,对自己所造成的一些现象的故事。% S9 v+ P1 C/ o' {) _

, h4 D/ P! @5 R; U第二部是《加油站袭击事件》,和李成宰合演的,韩片的另类之作,我最喜欢的韩国电影之一,99年卖座亚军。
! X) m+ m5 o) d
) E8 w$ V- J5 D《凶咒》也是有哲理的一部鬼片。刘2000共拍三部影片,它只是其中一部。另二部《同感》和《烈火狂奔》都是进入2000年十大卖座片。
/ N& e' u6 F/ {4 h" n0 a
' [9 ?- [: D/ z2000年的刘智泰是只要有机会,就不会放弃,所以他什么片子都接。4 H3 S, D* f+ Q- x- x! R! n5 j

: h' ?6 ~. d* f2 |- b* K8 |刘智泰和申河均都是我看好的实力派接班人。接几个老国宝的棒。9 X% E4 E% L( J/ m3 D7 `- U% u8 F

+ C; r% l( F0 L/ r& U' k+ O/ F( N现在的刘接片很挑剔,《OLD BOY》是朴赞郁的剧本打动他,他不介意当老崔的配角。刘2004的新作叫《Woman is the Future of Man 》,和《JSA》演出南韩士兵,《巴士站》演出老师的金泰佑合演,能让已在日本攻读导演专业的刘暂时放弃学业再度拍片,肯定是部不错的片子。. J1 i# `  [& F9 q

; v) V. M5 I* C6 Q/ D, }! B$ s《蔷花》是一部有深度的电影,并不是只有故事性,我认为它的故事性并不吸引人,重要的是编导挖掘引申它的内涵,从家庭的悲剧管窥社会的悲剧,世界的冷漠,它让我想起春上村树的小说,王家卫的电影,许美静的歌。
! a' h  l) Z+ H) G# [& C( j4 B" Q5 q6 o; @
[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2004-3-18 at 12:56 AM ]
此时无声胜有声

5

主题

506

回帖

585

积分

青铜长老

积分
585
发表于 2004-3-1 19:42 | 显示全部楼层
我觉得镜子中的悬疑是占重点的 比如看名字就知道是说关于镜子的 看第一个死者的死 就知道镜子里肯定有些什么 再看到刘智泰的回忆 就知道他肯定因为镜子有些障碍而到最后这种障碍会消失(虽然没消失。。但是是起了变化的)后来看到百货公司的show 那么多镜子 我就知道死者被藏在镜子里了 当然看的时候不是一下子全部谜底都揭开的 这点比较有趣 一边看一边发现 觉得很带劲
0 @. d- R: \* I蔷花就不一样了 其实开始我没有发现妹妹已经死了 只是知道姐姐的精神状态有问题 主要关注的是继母和他们之间的矛盾 而到最后 继母说你会后悔的时候 突然知道了其实妹妹已经死了之前都是姐姐的幻象 看着姐姐一个人坐在河边 无比悲哀啊。。。
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

联系我们|手机版|小黑屋|韩剧社区 ( 蜀ICP备14001718号 )

JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!

GMT+8, 2025-2-2 15:51 , Processed in 0.042398 second(s), 22 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.5

© 2001-2024 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表