找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 2186|回复: 3

【资料】Koreanfilm.org Critics Poll--2005

[复制链接]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
发表于 2005-8-6 07:44 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
20055 Y8 D0 _: W& o+ D, f

+ J4 f4 L; |* y5 X+ D% `. }) VThe Aggressives   
$ T  v; n" d& D$ u$ E# H   4 e  }' y6 R) i
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星       3 f- o* \( e( |% V# v
Darcy Paquet      两颗星  3 Z6 |* [- ~" R8 u, n

( `& O! j6 c" M0 S% i  Good stunts. Flat, uninteresting characters.
3 J5 {5 T  |; O9 F2 b   Has technical flair, but none of the poetry of Take Care Of My Cat.& D( \  g8 E" d& l

1 E) Q4 V% q! ^! w$ t/ Q. j: h
2 f% E7 X7 M$ l   
" O5 D2 Z1 O3 S8 [: rAnother Public Enemy   (公共之敌 2)
  f9 j6 v; e. R) N   * n9 L. m8 z# B! F% E  Q; F
Tom Giammarco  三颗星7 X$ z; {/ L" F8 b! m
Darcy Paquet      两颗半星
! D0 J2 T6 D6 R2 U/ F
" H  ]6 w; B" ~Not a bad action movie but LONG. I kept checking my watch.
% N7 c3 a5 b& hSuffers from a lack of efficiency.
2 [! |& m3 _5 M5 e7 N    ! \& d8 B# H8 ~. _9 u
Antarctic Journal   (南极日记)2 c4 ?" O# W, }
   
- B1 J, c% M! k. m0 @: _Tom Giammarco    三颗星
7 d1 `7 h$ b9 gAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星; a5 I/ o# O& K$ Q
Darcy Paquet   两颗半星  u1 X2 ]& k3 \0 o3 l3 G
' P5 ^4 F& i+ [6 X2 u& t9 k# G
Expected so much more. Curse of the Korean blockbusters resumes.
7 a$ Y) B2 K3 [8 k# |2 rLeft me cold.
' B+ ]4 F/ K$ }  W4 p2 }Starts off nice, but then loses its compass.
) B8 o$ }0 D3 L' i, R+ y0 ?+ G) F. K6 ]0 J

! w! ^8 b+ O" l  d+ y3 ]A Bittersweet Life   (甜蜜的人生)7 S9 r8 u; q! @6 @' G
   ) w2 K5 b, r; F0 u5 H; _+ `
Paolo Bertolin      四颗星; n8 X( g0 ^  n2 ?: I& m  T2 e
Tom Giammarco  四颗星
/ j$ R$ d, o* Z7 R* zDarcy Paquet  三颗半星
3 R2 @( y) ^8 A1 L# y8 y$ |Mark Russell   两颗半星+ @7 g4 o1 I, [& c+ l6 h
; |/ O# |. k8 G2 d& I/ f3 t
Kim's lavish visuals enriched by full-fledged dramatic consistency.
5 \$ V. C1 W9 m+ W# S! kStylish violence and excellent characterizations.
) O) @& l# g3 P* e" I  K- BMovie to show friends who liked Old Boy.
+ y' g+ k4 {, mSlick-looking but empty, with endless, pointless violence.
; k- @1 x' I( Q& M, N' m5 p2 g( l5 s4 z% }  {9 q' e+ }
The Bow     V! i  ~' N( a) t5 V
   6 b. P1 Y( l" o, S" E
Paolo Bertolin   两颗半星3 F# n# E, [9 g& g! n: O* U
Darcy Paquet   一颗半星
' k0 k" u6 I# m: d( n+ N; d8 w: h1 V: G  L3 N
Feels like a mild "best of" for festivals and Western audiences.
0 r7 b+ H5 e" d2 iKim Ki-duk on autopilot. 0 t/ G8 q* ~7 {: k) Q, ?
. v( x" l6 Z, K, q% s
" Q2 z% w! ]) c) `% `/ K% [( W
Brainwave   
, v* C7 T( ?6 A* }2 d   % G( R( _$ |: W! c
Tom Giammarco    三颗半星
: L" c1 R0 z# a5 Q1 x5 hAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星) N. H9 F6 }1 I* U- V* S# [

+ V! |; t2 c8 \( E% C: |! O3 f" QEnjoyable low-budget sci-fi but its vision was beyond its budget.
& F2 ^% e' L, o' P; ]/ w. rNow I know why Terminator was not shot with a handycam.
1 u4 L- B6 a, }5 L, h" \3 T' M1 c* R% I
    - ^- m. x" B8 Z& R# d+ g
Crying Fist   (哭泣的拳头)
0 j8 J' s: _# ~   1 m1 m1 V; t" M8 d5 m2 @' w
Tom Giammarco    四颗星
# s  d# T4 ^4 A- I+ O& c' u- ZAdrien Gombeaud  三颗半星
2 e/ p# v# u" j* y, U) E" tDarcy Paquet       四颗星
- G/ ~/ F  e) |' E! @3 t4 _
: k4 y; H, W9 ]8 cRyoo Seung-beom's acting elevates the film from good to great. 3 t5 y5 d/ P9 l- s" ^2 [" E
Hurts so good. ! O) D# `+ M; j, s
Gives the boxing film genre a punch in the ribs. + ]$ j5 y% l2 [0 q
3 i0 ]5 t9 ?0 J& @7 A2 a
    : R) J7 ~2 `9 \& q5 b& F
Feathers in the Wind (Git)   (风之羽)
3 U& j" z- l1 r# v$ P0 c   
5 J6 o0 J# [2 ^9 H8 g4 yPaolo Bertolin 三颗半星
9 L2 a: F$ ]" U" P; J. N' b( q8 pDavide Cazzaro  四颗星
6 O3 y( n6 m! w2 u$ _Tom Giammarco  四颗半星 7 Q+ O  ~  A$ H% E8 |
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星
, Q4 n  ?" w0 m* w( hMark Russell  三颗星
  {4 k7 m4 A" Y6 V1 `7 K7 C* d. P1 c6 a" J: v  ?$ p- X
Light as a feather, a small film often touched by grace. 0 N2 v/ E/ C% b+ O' K9 p  ]
Definitely one of the best Korean films produced in 2004. + F. f: k% b1 R. Q$ d0 S
Beautiful images, expertly paced story and interesting characters
3 s" F: t! n( zKorea's most exciting screen romance in a very long time.
9 ~1 b& I2 R" t* x, JNice little film, but nothing special. * l/ M. ]( f. D! k

4 b6 S* o9 C6 Q2 @; X8 VGreen Chair   (绿椅子)
2 I+ U  M$ F( ]8 v2 F2 w   
2 t" [2 Z0 c$ C$ T+ l/ V& S! M6 tPaolo Bertolin 四颗星" z$ O3 V" ]6 z' U# O" f
Davide Cazzaro  三颗星1 m0 N  m0 S1 ]6 }* I. z+ @
Filmbrain   三颗星1 o9 {3 N, C) v2 ^$ l  v3 ]
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星
5 B. u- z4 j6 g* D3 KAdam Hartzell 三颗星
+ Z1 {; N# f, \: ?$ MDarcy Paquet  四颗星
! T+ e* R, f) L& V1 [* x$ r  V' e4 W# R

5 C: d' m9 H- s( h+ S* ^8 G Asks the right questions in the proper manner. Heart-warming sex. - `# c) |. _- u$ ~
Good development of the story and fresh ideas. A little long.
& k# Z6 ?% \% a9 A+ E3 y& T8 p! DDaring, unconventional, sexy, and full of unexpected pleasures.: `& \$ I" j3 |% f
This would have been much better as a short film. Last 20 mins good. 4 f& W2 x& U0 O1 S# l7 m
Park peeps behind the Green Chair and finds more Park particulars.
! D$ e7 W6 }* QIrreverent and obnoxious, but still very touching.
- B, w1 G2 i7 _6 N
' c$ P/ K% W' m2 G4 S: K    : h/ D# {. a/ E* r+ o3 s4 |+ F
If You Were Me 2   (如果你是我 2 )& Y( a( n" o- E% U+ Q& A
   
9 D& o2 y$ |7 }, |Tom Giammarco  四颗半星
. F+ M& r' ^8 J) p8 YDarcy Paquet  三颗半星+ z* ]1 ?2 g  J+ @. M$ U! o/ T/ h. z; k' |, D
/ M! n  n4 z' N3 A) ]/ m
Arguably better than the original. Tightly focused storytelling.
* \/ N/ `. u5 u6 I0 u5 ~! O1 EA well-formed omnibus (which is rare). Jung Ji-woo's is my favorite.
  e1 f8 w1 b1 \: U
! D: p4 R4 f3 X( v
; q7 B! Z5 {8 t7 f$ r1 d   
2 l3 C8 g6 z. }! i8 bInnocent Steps   ( 舞女纯情)
. W4 z& a$ e' J   4 B6 v9 e6 g7 m+ F) u
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星
% `% G3 l- f9 `4 qDarcy Paquet  一颗半星
/ X+ Q! b. _% a% ]4 r0 ?- {- d7 F: g9 i: z4 z  l% ]) H
Disappointing and cliche.
- P. n7 }9 d- O8 d6 l, NI wish the screenwriter had just let them dance.
% M% K; J; Q( A3 g+ L( n! j7 m. g% W

. [5 J& `) O5 _2 e
1 V/ j) C  T( O- p1 X1 z( P. \Jenny, Juno   
' ^; D5 ?$ H% B! O0 P' w! H   
- x) @& H1 i) B, x2 W1 D4 v0 iTom Giammarco  一颗星
4 ^. ~( r( z8 ^0 ]( h' W9 @Kyu Hyun  Kim  一颗半星* E3 L1 n$ J& u. ~" U
Elif Kaya  两颗半星$ v' j* R5 k6 d' w  A
Darcy Paquet  两颗星
9 R1 W5 A' @9 Z. \
+ u$ _) r# c- O8 PTreats the subject of early-teen pregnancy much too lightly. % I7 t9 i$ }) J' |' w% D
Good Lord. Makes Blue Lagoon look like Umbrellas of Cherbourg .
$ c  z0 ^  Y1 o0 v0 RStylish, feel good film, not much else is there though.
0 X% Q# s  b$ Y1 K( @& _) NI was enjoying this movie, and then I started to hate it. ; G/ ~" d0 R1 Q: K, L

3 I: E- j& P& v0 d7 w& {5 A   
" h5 Y, n( }) V! j# ?$ MMapado   (麻婆岛)
: T2 K3 T. w/ Y) {7 f! ?  U   * Z3 H0 R% T0 G( S5 W, v( ?6 V
Paolo Bertolin 两颗星$ \1 A. m5 T. m
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星
1 G; e5 f' a( C7 C0 `. J8 @% f# |- R) D* u  \5 A) c
Formulaic characters and contrived plot. Obnoxious and trivial.
2 M$ A1 h' z' e9 t, r6 XNeed to turn off your brain to get through this comedy.
! m( F9 U$ Z& m: y& A- e5 O$ V; a  J3 |9 ]. T; E% \, ~
   
0 Y/ N9 W% ]( s5 pMarathon   (马拉松)- u) ]% W1 A7 z' X
   
1 A0 }; \' N) X5 V( `1 d& wPaolo Bertolin  一颗半
3 K" [, i, R: ?, M6 w% J) hTom Giammarco  四颗半
' R3 ]; A( ]# f. c6 X; Y. x' N  q9 I5 U) M1 f- o1 }# Q8 y* _. `7 F
Typical Korean woman-basher: it's all mum's fault! Cho overdoes it.
; D+ U) y' D+ A# m' K& c+ T( _Excellent performances shine in this touching story.
6 l7 N* F0 Y/ Y3 i( h0 m
8 G- ^' }1 t7 b/ E# _1 Y. M* q2 q4 t
My Boyfriend is Type-B   (我的B型男友)- j! O4 J9 Q) K# _0 w, }5 V
   
) t6 ?- i0 z) H, @Tom Giammarco  . 两颗星
4 C( O# |/ [8 ~; }Elif Kaya   两颗星4 Q+ Z0 ?- p! o/ [/ f
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星7 y4 ]2 ?: Q/ c) W5 t  ?
   
6 n4 [1 w! f: {3 _% mCouldn't stand the characters. No chemistry between the leads9 ?2 z9 S; A8 l  ?* H! p1 i4 s
Lacklustre rom com, only if you like any of the lead actors./ a% h5 E* }, D( }- @$ ^+ g
How about that Lotte product placement? " c6 x! k0 g: ^2 M& I" y$ Z3 a6 q

) f' X* o; P2 k, u6 x! ?; ^5 W/ H( G# CPossible Changes   (可能的变化)
# Q  x5 p" L" r2 M   5 R/ E6 L  H+ A! s3 b. F
Davide Cazzaro 一颗星) m) [6 [: I0 Z4 z( a( ?
Tom Giammarco  一颗星
" C1 |+ T/ d$ B6 {Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
( D) B) K0 [% H$ n( \. s2 Q
. i' Y7 a+ @% ^4 E, e% o3 ]& o6 RFormer assistant to Hong Sang-soo tried to make a Hong film.
9 d% k; C" ]  k. c  CSomber, depressing, stagnant and pointless. 9 {0 C$ z1 @; ]  @+ [
Maybe I missed something. I don't think so. * b3 v' g8 f* k- m& w: x$ A- _
8 d& ?( n( a5 p; F2 J- a& X. L
; q; E- z+ s0 r; U

' o% E# o+ S: h8 O0 e: Q( }  m8 g2 |" t- q  V! o
The President's Last Bang   (那时代,那些人)
2 V1 \3 L% x( l, N3 x; |   
3 E) N( ~1 P/ R% ~, lPaolo Bertolin  三颗半星
5 O! C5 ~9 t/ ]0 z: {) x) }1 x  u: a6 b8 PJames Brown  三颗半星: K" v+ ^) u6 w$ z( F( S2 U
Davide Cazzaro  四颗半星1 O* H% q  E" g9 J/ L7 X
Filmbrain 四颗半星1 ~! p: B7 e& S6 Q5 Q6 Q1 n; s
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星$ t' X0 v5 Q9 r& R* J
Mark Russell  四颗星) r4 i8 U3 \9 p4 Z* Y
Boris Trbic  三颗半星8 W# W4 i) n4 n# P9 [/ H

" W5 [+ A) ?/ p, U# m6 {' \$ E- tIm knows how to dare, and his ambition and bravery deserve praise. 0 J+ ]- R. A( |1 I. e- Y$ Q& W, K$ T2 @
Hip, intrepid piece but its irreverence is just a touch too zealous.
8 z# D+ [& ^, O$ K( t4 x4 _Witty, provocative and mordent. A "must not miss" Korean film. + D8 ~5 U) j! d; U4 U1 b
Brilliant political satire that easily ranks with the best. $ D7 B' ?* N9 [: ?4 A8 W" b
Baek Yoon-shik is a god, and Im Sang-soo is a master. ; ?% v. `! ?# a" [- j2 ]
Maybe not great history, but a great film. Dark and funny.
4 K4 I+ m5 [7 pUndressing fascism can be fun. Gloomy and entertaining.  
, @2 x$ g: }' W; i" G( v( P( s
8 m; c. Z# G- Z* i    / L  J7 K; N9 z
Red Eye   (红眼)2 \  h; B9 A. ]3 g. B$ |
   
- y8 t' V3 ]/ c9 q7 l; TTom Giammarco  两颗星
& D2 J; E: @7 t* ZKyu Hyun  Kim  两颗半星7 @) K% E5 ?7 O7 z+ A1 C& ?
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
- `8 d8 x0 h* G6 r+ M
" ~' S& x- Y6 T, [ An embarrassment to ghosts everywhere.
7 ~: b8 a( G) z  ~8 s. g  e" `7 MNo Oriental Express, but I rather fancied the train setting. : v. S% B# W! G+ P* c! R9 j  e
Nice cast, but none of the emotions in the film hit home.
, S9 x1 s$ w5 F, o7 |; l' d, B: T- @4 a
   . ~/ `! Z& R( s/ j
The Red Shoes   (红鞋)
; ^4 {* ?/ G6 i9 l7 I4 X   9 A* a3 J5 K; C. m% @8 m
Tom Giammarco  三颗半星2 h! T% m- N  E* }6 p
Kyu Hyun  Kim  三颗星
$ c, B( I% N( D$ t" \* @3 XDarcy Paquet  两颗半星
" f5 c. y$ b. i0 ]' R9 }  V/ z9 U& M4 ^: h6 V
Kim Hye-su is excellent/Plot has many holes but manages to scare. : N4 g/ n' Q1 E/ ^- t
The shoes are, uh, pink. At least Kim Hye-su dances to her tune. 0 e* s: b; S, u# Q8 K' a
An A for style, a C- for enlightened creativity. / M" F# A; o  m! Y. u8 Q

  Y+ W; e, A5 l/ K) V$ E8 Z" b% g
Road   (公路)1 I3 A2 W. E5 d8 @( w+ c
   + l$ g1 I6 v% ^# S0 j
Davide Cazzaro  三颗星/ `3 ^  W) Z+ a# {
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星% Q0 b- \) i2 t" D& K6 |
Darcy Paquet  三颗星
7 S1 o7 q  _: O: c
3 w- R0 J. `/ n' x* j3 ~& F, aNothing very new but Bae Chang-ho shows his talent and experience.0 V' v% s: J& Y; p6 h
Great cinematography & story. Not perfect due to lead actress.
# Y/ f: B: r6 l) A5 a1 f9 a6 KIts slow-building emotional power is its greatest strength.
2 D- N3 d/ q- r% Q4 ]" ~9 K( `! n6 {4 R
" u  }( N% n* Q
( L+ ?/ p: G7 P( \7 A. F8 A
Spying Cam   / P" @( Q' }- ^* m2 d8 X2 o
   " `  c) }7 z1 @/ Q2 Q% L
Paolo Bertolin  四颗星( t4 F) y1 P( f/ Y/ U2 z
Darcy Paquet  两颗半星! v7 Q. s8 u4 ~& N6 ^
* M5 _6 Q, i$ ], [6 t9 h) O. M
Korean political background, yet universal ethics in a great film.
3 @4 K3 [) K& S- {Made with passion but not quite as much precision.
  V/ _- Z; d' }9 N/ W
# l9 x; q/ C% K, a$ s
2 x  y- O/ q+ y- T- z   
; P6 x- k- p1 @0 l: u  ?7 M3 C# u( vTale of Cinema   (剧场前)
2 q# x7 [# Z- f' B% \" a   
" j& b$ z+ j8 [& J3 _Paolo Bertolin 两颗星4 D- D" i- w& |& L" I# a
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星, P; |% p$ D1 i3 H: V" X( A
Mark Russell  两颗星
! ?2 [. |+ Q- ~' M6 ^  x9 l1 r4 p% H8 ?. c& y/ W/ b( S* t
An utter disappointment. Is Hong running out of inspiration? ) t/ `2 I. n+ R' d
Do I detect a tiny glimpse of optimism in this film? ; F. D3 B2 f, t1 X! w3 V) z
..ooOOoo....ooOOoo... Love that zoom. Dull and uninspired. ) D& e9 V/ O7 E& p7 Q

8 Z$ \( S3 k6 p: Q' K& d. I" B- g' w% ?
' g. W3 v# S% t  p
    & Y  I: I. E4 e# ]
This Charming Girl   (女子晴惠)* b) u7 h- B) v8 O9 _
   
, S: l; M4 J/ ~: R7 l& QDavide Cazzaro  四颗星* d" G8 S& l9 F& O; A  ^- k3 c
Filmbrain  三颗半星
# R' n2 ~1 {, l* r1 ~9 z* ?Tom Giammarco  四颗半星
% W# _4 J. @8 ^Adrien Gombeaud  五颗星+ E2 n1 j) ^6 X; a7 s
Adam Hartzell  三颗半星' S; j! d; d+ x/ a2 i- e6 x& S
Kyu Hyun  Kim  四颗星
' A  \6 w  ~1 R6 e* t& TDarcy Paquet  三颗半星/ I$ p- I. P3 L- f) T: A
/ z3 D1 S3 N: S
Probably the best debut of 2004. Let's keep an eye on Lee Yoon-ki. 1 N' R8 _; J- O9 H3 @  }! g
Small, quiet, subtle. The kind of film we need to see more of.
# j+ ]( x! Y: D( mAmazing film giving intricate details of the life of one woman.
4 b9 \3 O0 G6 c# ^5 D8 F. QShe walks in beauty.
2 a1 b& v9 d0 @0 a, D( G" r) INot a jumped-up postal girl, but an intriguing character study. ) N1 E; P2 e5 C' O4 S
Finally, a filmic antidote to the "YOU WANNA DIE?" Sassy Girls.
! m  O% ^0 e5 x* N2 a# wA quiet but strong film. Kim Ji-soo is worth following
+ J0 K: K* i: {) A- h* e) a; J/ o7 Q* f7 N; O* M  @
[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2005-8-6 at 10:37 ]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-6 07:54 | 显示全部楼层

包括了很多2005年以来放映的韩片,好像截止到六月份

以上只是KOREANFILM.ORG这个网站中的人员的一些投票,他们的口味偏专家一些,也许和一般的观众有点点不一样.即便里面的人,有时候针对一部电影,也会有截然不同的结果.
  e5 `! Z( }1 t+ u' M+ Z( ^
0 v1 ~+ A0 E# A7 v$ p( _看了这么多,感觉好像到2005年的六月份为止,在超过一百万人次的电影中,<那时代,那些人>获得这些影评人的很高的评价,<甜蜜人生>和<哭泣的拳头>也是评价也很不错的,小众电影中,<女子晴惠>,<风之羽><绿椅子>等也是评价非常不错.<南极日记>比较惨,是输了票房,又输了影评的那种两头不落好的电影(成功的商业电影也不是好做的),<公共之敌2>,<麻婆岛>至少还有票房在,<马拉松>好象评价很极端,个人认为还是艺术质量还不错的大众片.金基德和洪尚秀今年的作品似乎并不被这些影评人欣赏.
0 R: ^8 [/ X  \
7 I& w, d0 U# B. S[ Last edited by lwang on 2005-8-6 at 08:03 ]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
发表于 2005-8-6 11:24 | 显示全部楼层
目前截止,,<那时代,那些人>的确是上半年的翘楚之作!!8 W* d2 Z- T4 C' c- x
他们对<哭泣的拳头>评价不错,但个人感觉真是一般啊!!柳没什么特色!
此时无声胜有声

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-7 10:28 | 显示全部楼层
<亲切的金子>也许会是下半年最重要的作品了. 就目前所知道的这些有名的导演的作品来看,也就这部值得看了.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

联系我们|手机版|小黑屋|韩剧社区 ( 蜀ICP备14001718号 )

JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!

GMT+8, 2024-5-27 11:16 , Processed in 0.037800 second(s), 23 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.5

© 2001-2024 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表