找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 2221|回复: 3

【资料】Koreanfilm.org Critics Poll--2005

[复制链接]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
发表于 2005-8-6 07:44 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
2005* l# _/ G+ C% W$ g- @7 D
; T% h' h' x" A9 z* }  f
The Aggressives   
% B5 ]6 E& {, z( ^, s$ p: i. C: N   
$ [5 d3 `& x: O3 n0 ^Tom Giammarco  两颗半星       - h5 H- p/ T! o5 w) S0 y' ~4 J
Darcy Paquet      两颗星  
+ ]$ y# _# F6 m6 l8 V  Z/ J% G/ I) W6 ]. b
  Good stunts. Flat, uninteresting characters.
# E; B- Z' n: e4 l   Has technical flair, but none of the poetry of Take Care Of My Cat.$ v' x" b# j8 L5 f/ O
% F. B% _* G( I' b( ?: a+ ?, L" Y2 t

; Z# D" y8 ~- W    ( u$ h0 ]" M  b, \- W$ n6 {$ Q
Another Public Enemy   (公共之敌 2)" C; J' q3 ~' E/ }0 E- _
   3 p! |  ~- L& s3 v
Tom Giammarco  三颗星5 a5 a% K7 T* i
Darcy Paquet      两颗半星7 {1 h& E: M$ {, j, x7 [$ u! i! A* |, R$ z
+ `" l& W) {- l! `$ g0 R# V* m
Not a bad action movie but LONG. I kept checking my watch.
  A3 D! {( L4 @Suffers from a lack of efficiency. ! t! Z6 X4 g4 H8 L: i7 r7 Q5 O
    7 b5 Q! d% o) J7 n% g9 O
Antarctic Journal   (南极日记)
1 F3 y5 ?+ C7 G. M4 B+ h! J7 C( ]   : p. e6 g4 b" M+ u
Tom Giammarco    三颗星
9 T0 a4 c) Z8 TAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星7 J: t1 L" \) Z, l% J2 ~
Darcy Paquet   两颗半星' J# p9 M6 T. o, q
" B' W# e6 h. O4 A2 G- Z5 T
Expected so much more. Curse of the Korean blockbusters resumes. " J# Y. H  O2 P
Left me cold. ! b0 d6 f: v- l( C1 W" z2 \* y
Starts off nice, but then loses its compass. # O& Y. z! `8 R1 r
: c0 B$ T7 B5 y0 T& f7 A7 c) h

0 {( ~# V/ Z! C, PA Bittersweet Life   (甜蜜的人生)5 D& B; D3 t+ d' h6 c
   
$ c( C7 ~* r' L7 c; a% u: l- e- qPaolo Bertolin      四颗星" x9 T7 f! q0 n' Z: B% ]
Tom Giammarco  四颗星6 |4 |6 ^* C0 `) L, Y/ K
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星
2 M0 S, s# y( K& i5 ]9 r# @; jMark Russell   两颗半星: ]! v6 v! u6 p5 X
, f# E( ^4 b4 u1 P7 k8 n7 G& Q
Kim's lavish visuals enriched by full-fledged dramatic consistency.
6 I( o5 A& K% ]+ ^. ~1 X$ hStylish violence and excellent characterizations.
! ]# p8 ?6 D3 C- X+ \. I" M, Q$ ]Movie to show friends who liked Old Boy.) I: v9 d  Z: ]7 X8 |' h5 B
Slick-looking but empty, with endless, pointless violence.
7 L" o$ I+ s# T* b( l
1 J3 w% p( c& A7 @The Bow   : v- ^# ^" U( o& a  M
   " x( C* l$ m! v
Paolo Bertolin   两颗半星
. p& U4 ~5 E3 G8 D' z4 YDarcy Paquet   一颗半星+ R6 ~) s; N1 S; U5 ?3 q! k

3 [+ a* a) V7 d* xFeels like a mild "best of" for festivals and Western audiences.' P3 O( N4 p9 k
Kim Ki-duk on autopilot.
5 K4 k# E9 l# F9 l" V- J
2 z) ^% ^3 D, ~
. W" u9 r( \$ Z3 Q8 \Brainwave   
; r7 ~4 k9 P) Y+ Q6 D: z& ]   $ L" h$ X0 H1 c+ l
Tom Giammarco    三颗半星
# K" V2 x/ ^* SAdrien Gombeaud  一颗星
* M( L# A( \6 H. O) O: W# a9 i& a  t1 R; e- H' _/ i1 q/ c" j1 u
Enjoyable low-budget sci-fi but its vision was beyond its budget. 9 o1 ~- W/ _5 `8 a% b5 q& A; n0 m
Now I know why Terminator was not shot with a handycam.
# X4 a  h, O4 |* @/ R8 x/ u; s
6 {9 O- s* c; r6 q$ ~  `, s; w% b    6 @- ^8 T% c6 V% {
Crying Fist   (哭泣的拳头). ]# g' Q' M5 i# e1 Q
   . v' B5 O$ Y' l+ _/ \
Tom Giammarco    四颗星
! S. e7 k$ [3 c: I; L3 T" d3 h# BAdrien Gombeaud  三颗半星! u! R1 [3 i; q0 V2 c" R
Darcy Paquet       四颗星) g& ^  U6 S( J2 ]+ T! J
6 Q7 Y8 d# r2 g* N
Ryoo Seung-beom's acting elevates the film from good to great. + M: h5 @: s1 x! q
Hurts so good. " E1 ]4 |8 K9 I
Gives the boxing film genre a punch in the ribs.
0 M1 Z; y/ ?2 P/ w: P, u
4 S5 Y+ Q; H& T" U2 K    7 V/ Q- j& P0 r/ e2 V
Feathers in the Wind (Git)   (风之羽)
2 N. |" I* f! Y5 h- U8 j   4 N2 g! G5 }. r3 w, X
Paolo Bertolin 三颗半星
8 z) U( d  K, D* R8 ZDavide Cazzaro  四颗星1 U. F& r, K) y( Y: Y' g
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星 5 o2 o; Z4 p% u. r2 d! v
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星
+ \+ Z( H0 j/ B  J$ l6 K7 u5 _) a7 TMark Russell  三颗星7 m6 s  }& @. p- h! F; A) K

) d% P, j' n4 D2 dLight as a feather, a small film often touched by grace.
; B2 g- I. z9 ]Definitely one of the best Korean films produced in 2004. * U9 w( ^. S$ F& f
Beautiful images, expertly paced story and interesting characters
4 a" o; }# Z2 K: \# gKorea's most exciting screen romance in a very long time. 0 Q# J7 S: j" C6 t1 l
Nice little film, but nothing special. & p4 u3 G2 r8 o. Y

3 s2 H- p4 c" T4 X  v+ J! v3 uGreen Chair   (绿椅子)
9 M, d8 B! Z) {5 L   
$ \1 }+ f1 x/ l, Q# t  g6 oPaolo Bertolin 四颗星
% ?% o3 o/ y- P+ g% c" j7 Y, u4 M$ _Davide Cazzaro  三颗星
0 K( M4 L0 C6 s. x8 u8 X! @Filmbrain   三颗星
* K& v* x, T7 d/ S- z  T* wTom Giammarco  两颗半星- G7 r$ V3 e6 ~, t& I* B
Adam Hartzell 三颗星
7 a$ a7 |& U" MDarcy Paquet  四颗星
6 N7 y7 }5 f8 k, |* b' T* ~3 `% g* n  J8 x
# I  i; p0 H3 ^3 _# e! ^. P8 _1 m) |
Asks the right questions in the proper manner. Heart-warming sex.
# F5 V$ W, v) Q: a6 b+ WGood development of the story and fresh ideas. A little long. % S6 ^1 {+ R: r' f
Daring, unconventional, sexy, and full of unexpected pleasures.
" t  X, x- x9 q; `! E6 CThis would have been much better as a short film. Last 20 mins good. : S' F: K- j- P2 j4 r& k1 G
Park peeps behind the Green Chair and finds more Park particulars.
* t1 k+ u% }& l' S7 |9 gIrreverent and obnoxious, but still very touching. 9 @4 E* G8 o; o0 s4 D
* T2 P. M" E5 C# M' n. h9 V
    6 z2 I) G+ v' t- g3 q/ ?
If You Were Me 2   (如果你是我 2 )% H+ ?# Q9 T' f* {
   2 p% j+ `' g& h9 B9 H9 g' e+ E  e, P
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星3 t, P" A7 \/ u8 {$ Q9 l
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星
: B9 P& |6 W2 \0 U, c- A$ j) h0 H' n
Arguably better than the original. Tightly focused storytelling. 2 e9 y, h% s7 l  F# q
A well-formed omnibus (which is rare). Jung Ji-woo's is my favorite. 3 F$ C( W4 E+ F9 S3 i
  G. h, h+ `" m) e0 S& K" `
) [# G' C1 A" Y3 S8 l- ^6 y
   
: R" G  R  c4 fInnocent Steps   ( 舞女纯情)
( l! m2 ]; |$ W2 C, E" d   : ]+ i& T5 x5 z- {
Tom Giammarco  两颗半星
+ u2 u; Q# K: m# u) pDarcy Paquet  一颗半星7 P1 e( o. b6 a% u- @( F- \

! M9 O2 x( Y, {) o. P3 p) XDisappointing and cliche.
% t; B6 Q) R# g$ O; SI wish the screenwriter had just let them dance. 4 M8 A6 \7 `5 c' H6 G7 v& b( l
* G( F! i) k5 l( b/ K0 m/ J
+ P% D! E: A  A) H( T8 J
; a8 C' }. @0 b
Jenny, Juno   ! j9 a; D; z% f' d6 `
   $ B/ j8 b% v, q7 z3 p1 b4 [3 ~3 ~
Tom Giammarco  一颗星5 H9 `# K3 p) a: O7 d- l
Kyu Hyun  Kim  一颗半星
$ p( ~& @) ~# k8 o8 {% eElif Kaya  两颗半星
2 `1 h- Q. U5 S2 bDarcy Paquet  两颗星: D8 ^4 U) n3 z# Q8 {

4 {3 J/ c+ h( bTreats the subject of early-teen pregnancy much too lightly.
4 K1 `! C1 H7 r  b4 N& lGood Lord. Makes Blue Lagoon look like Umbrellas of Cherbourg .
( s0 f. ~4 j, C, N- TStylish, feel good film, not much else is there though. % }( [1 g, B+ x) m6 w
I was enjoying this movie, and then I started to hate it.
$ K' d7 t% k2 c" p6 \7 A8 e& [; y
( L- M! H! D4 u7 I   * i3 g: _" L4 \3 M+ Z7 O
Mapado   (麻婆岛)
( r3 k8 r' S2 M, z) U! Z, _   
5 S2 n1 P1 e4 [- }/ ~Paolo Bertolin 两颗星
: B+ b, n6 F: i5 ZTom Giammarco  两颗半星
$ \8 u8 |- f; o! r- i# j
- `. `) z8 z# L3 |Formulaic characters and contrived plot. Obnoxious and trivial. 0 Q- c3 H" m; G" t' A8 D; Q
Need to turn off your brain to get through this comedy.
: ~# S: K) R. X" f% z' \: [" e. N- n+ f# l
   
$ M+ w$ d' V% v0 s4 {Marathon   (马拉松)- O: Z2 G, _+ w  j9 }
   0 D$ a* L2 z$ X3 }) `7 ]2 x5 s
Paolo Bertolin  一颗半- b  \; t" t, n# Y- c
Tom Giammarco  四颗半
" l5 z1 w: ~3 z0 U: H* B
/ X# N5 J& t& S: A8 z( p$ BTypical Korean woman-basher: it's all mum's fault! Cho overdoes it.
3 o  _' Q" `: `) A" P" tExcellent performances shine in this touching story. ! ?8 r" s' U  I4 F
9 c0 W7 \3 O' [9 m3 r( e0 q

3 G+ z9 B" y% w2 W+ F! _2 KMy Boyfriend is Type-B   (我的B型男友)
& p- F, p  W2 W, p! r7 ~   0 ~7 L- \3 `1 m9 Z! V
Tom Giammarco  . 两颗星
* W& @/ B! S3 n1 ~, ^Elif Kaya   两颗星5 r+ D4 V/ N% X0 r1 ]  a
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
8 Q9 @' c/ C$ P% W$ w    ! W) E. d; I0 t4 S2 z( T
Couldn't stand the characters. No chemistry between the leads
- y* Q5 V' s/ w' _; I6 y0 OLacklustre rom com, only if you like any of the lead actors.& V4 E6 t  e8 M& k* I( h- ?5 X
How about that Lotte product placement? 7 q" U# V/ u, i# i6 U' r4 s- M

5 i! G8 Y: A- DPossible Changes   (可能的变化)
! |# C5 X: w: _. a; y& `   
7 ]& H! r) W: \' G8 RDavide Cazzaro 一颗星
7 F7 N, b8 Q0 \% f9 r- E& nTom Giammarco  一颗星7 r9 g4 W' T5 @/ i. u* z3 Z
Darcy Paquet  一颗半星' o# W6 D9 f% j# |9 O9 M. n" Z0 j

% c, m4 x* l: C2 m/ d! M( o6 r3 hFormer assistant to Hong Sang-soo tried to make a Hong film.
. Q9 k2 A( k: p0 j  nSomber, depressing, stagnant and pointless. " @0 _" r7 B1 d; o" A# l( c& K  O0 S
Maybe I missed something. I don't think so. $ b% {( C! d, K! T! ]) ~

. Y% _" ~7 y) o7 }8 |8 L
5 |5 {8 F" @: b9 \; }) B) Q
8 l/ M% m8 b2 q& o: `  q0 n! |& y8 G. I& K3 d
The President's Last Bang   (那时代,那些人)
! B4 j- h" |6 Z4 }   9 f$ X, n- H7 B
Paolo Bertolin  三颗半星( t2 I5 R- {3 D. z6 D- ^
James Brown  三颗半星
% i  E" I! z7 O6 a3 LDavide Cazzaro  四颗半星
5 {- S; J  B4 r/ m( YFilmbrain 四颗半星+ H7 Y1 W5 V  y9 g
Darcy Paquet  四颗半星8 D  Y( `; J! t7 W; l
Mark Russell  四颗星3 L9 w, i. I7 j6 ~) w# W
Boris Trbic  三颗半星
2 F. w# M! p3 D# i; k% Q" }) [! {6 g
Im knows how to dare, and his ambition and bravery deserve praise.   g. C6 Z: p& g9 I9 W2 t$ C' H0 V
Hip, intrepid piece but its irreverence is just a touch too zealous.
; t  o7 S+ m, p  \7 t+ aWitty, provocative and mordent. A "must not miss" Korean film.
2 E6 V  o1 l! k$ [ Brilliant political satire that easily ranks with the best. . t9 N$ I$ ?+ ]$ {8 b
Baek Yoon-shik is a god, and Im Sang-soo is a master.
! ?/ C; Q6 \% d" CMaybe not great history, but a great film. Dark and funny. 8 H0 u5 q3 v; z1 ]4 @: [
Undressing fascism can be fun. Gloomy and entertaining.  
$ Z; d& D  m% n: I
5 U, z2 g" S; R& |3 c% v; j   
  J2 S; _2 G% @, U9 \Red Eye   (红眼)
, w4 Q$ }5 r" v: E1 v) S  a+ ]! A   * j! w- Y5 F& ^) `2 K% N
Tom Giammarco  两颗星
& F. s  Q0 @! BKyu Hyun  Kim  两颗半星
& h8 E8 Y, u; |# ~- _Darcy Paquet  一颗半星
* D1 Z9 l* P+ i8 n* o3 _& J' p1 O$ F, f. P
An embarrassment to ghosts everywhere.
; b/ Q0 x: `4 r9 NNo Oriental Express, but I rather fancied the train setting.   u- p5 l3 a2 C2 Y
Nice cast, but none of the emotions in the film hit home. * r' Z! Y5 v3 ~" M) p

0 t! L; D' A9 g$ X. K   . Z5 y% K1 w# w, Z5 ^* l7 [
The Red Shoes   (红鞋)
1 q3 j" U  T0 f+ M* B5 t   2 T8 N! r& l$ R: H, p9 ^* D
Tom Giammarco  三颗半星
% W: O; w  n( y: G' W$ W* FKyu Hyun  Kim  三颗星7 ]/ P, k9 H" z7 j. N% n' e! Y
Darcy Paquet  两颗半星
4 i; N# \! O4 v! z
3 n: Q; Z# p6 vKim Hye-su is excellent/Plot has many holes but manages to scare. : e: a, _8 H7 q; G; _5 L* Z4 |, b
The shoes are, uh, pink. At least Kim Hye-su dances to her tune.
4 e! V5 A, K, g2 n" H9 cAn A for style, a C- for enlightened creativity.
# h- z! _4 L1 ?) `1 V% m# Z2 i6 I, W+ b, D
' _. `! |5 ~8 ~" ~( h
Road   (公路)
8 P( Z5 u) s/ n' h# t5 B   , L) x8 W$ I7 u; ]0 m9 u# h* ]& U
Davide Cazzaro  三颗星8 b( w6 `0 m  {( D2 p+ r7 Z5 M
Tom Giammarco  四颗半星) Y' B  z: w9 p8 t$ ]. w  Z6 Y+ ^( Z
Darcy Paquet  三颗星# I+ P9 @4 c2 M4 U- D* `7 F
- c3 [) f2 }: [9 i: @
Nothing very new but Bae Chang-ho shows his talent and experience.
) r" j+ J4 q5 s) p% |$ @1 R" xGreat cinematography & story. Not perfect due to lead actress. + z/ Y1 c3 A, F' Z8 A' J
Its slow-building emotional power is its greatest strength.
; w2 b* W; F/ n& l7 c2 K8 K, _: p& x2 \8 s. ?" W5 ?

8 Y9 F3 t) A& J4 `" e- E% G9 h1 b: o0 F0 b/ t6 E0 \  N
Spying Cam   + X6 n% C7 b' |
   ( b/ _  D  U2 \/ q/ I! C  ?# @# T: B. t
Paolo Bertolin  四颗星! g+ J! s( V6 D3 Z
Darcy Paquet  两颗半星  ?+ I* H# |# ], q+ P3 _1 A

) |: l  {/ o8 A2 X. n& w/ L. h& DKorean political background, yet universal ethics in a great film. / n& N/ k8 r; R) @7 [
Made with passion but not quite as much precision.
6 B4 V+ q; N6 Y4 c( ?) [8 R2 ^4 ~5 s- r$ M' o/ U- G! ~1 \
0 I. T4 ^5 E/ e: O0 K0 M
    * Z% O  Y* ~- s
Tale of Cinema   (剧场前)# E7 z3 I4 u) s/ h$ p( k
   
& h0 _6 w1 Z( G/ `, A9 i' yPaolo Bertolin 两颗星! c. d8 i6 u* T- k9 W3 \+ m
Darcy Paquet  三颗半星4 F" c7 O' L9 }  _
Mark Russell  两颗星; W$ ~0 H* ^. [

2 l$ k' @- O, v9 V9 I An utter disappointment. Is Hong running out of inspiration?
# l" _; C: @/ J7 h) u5 wDo I detect a tiny glimpse of optimism in this film? 8 e8 `, S! Q% e* D& g% @4 u
..ooOOoo....ooOOoo... Love that zoom. Dull and uninspired. 3 b; b& Q0 W: f2 d% K5 J' _8 m4 V

4 z% A6 Q) ?# ~3 l; Y1 p
! w/ l0 c$ ~! O/ I: |1 W; Y% Y! N
. B+ w- J: u) Q    - i0 d- T6 Z! v9 R$ x$ L
This Charming Girl   (女子晴惠)' G; n$ j- O5 {  p) s
   
) F' y+ {5 J! G* f2 C/ r  z1 B% qDavide Cazzaro  四颗星
3 `2 Q) M( Q- `7 }0 WFilmbrain  三颗半星
5 l  h- {, h' Y) CTom Giammarco  四颗半星
6 s+ ~/ V! A2 o. \( s! pAdrien Gombeaud  五颗星
  q% ~6 Z$ ~" F; d5 z( @Adam Hartzell  三颗半星
: ?, Q8 i4 c! a6 @8 G4 KKyu Hyun  Kim  四颗星
0 j' l+ o2 c0 D: x' [' S4 BDarcy Paquet  三颗半星
7 T$ ^% a8 k. K8 r3 q' D3 ?8 d, ~: @9 s  S9 S2 m& V+ ?
Probably the best debut of 2004. Let's keep an eye on Lee Yoon-ki.
0 @! X) T1 |3 T$ G0 [Small, quiet, subtle. The kind of film we need to see more of.
% @' B( i( t( W+ o6 y+ {$ _% q: IAmazing film giving intricate details of the life of one woman.
* x. M# F  Y- I" f6 X6 dShe walks in beauty. ) S8 L9 @1 M6 |5 u$ r) N/ p8 N& `1 R8 x" J
Not a jumped-up postal girl, but an intriguing character study.
% D9 T: {8 w0 U$ g5 w9 j. p/ oFinally, a filmic antidote to the "YOU WANNA DIE?" Sassy Girls. $ ]+ t3 g. b/ S5 F6 i
A quiet but strong film. Kim Ji-soo is worth following
8 u2 S. h1 u. W' C/ X
0 f: y  F" R, p& f. f  a' @$ }* d[ Last edited by 阿韩 on 2005-8-6 at 10:37 ]

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-6 07:54 | 显示全部楼层

包括了很多2005年以来放映的韩片,好像截止到六月份

以上只是KOREANFILM.ORG这个网站中的人员的一些投票,他们的口味偏专家一些,也许和一般的观众有点点不一样.即便里面的人,有时候针对一部电影,也会有截然不同的结果.
1 V1 V) |( [, p, W9 X8 P
0 F$ @& g7 Y/ N# d1 A看了这么多,感觉好像到2005年的六月份为止,在超过一百万人次的电影中,<那时代,那些人>获得这些影评人的很高的评价,<甜蜜人生>和<哭泣的拳头>也是评价也很不错的,小众电影中,<女子晴惠>,<风之羽><绿椅子>等也是评价非常不错.<南极日记>比较惨,是输了票房,又输了影评的那种两头不落好的电影(成功的商业电影也不是好做的),<公共之敌2>,<麻婆岛>至少还有票房在,<马拉松>好象评价很极端,个人认为还是艺术质量还不错的大众片.金基德和洪尚秀今年的作品似乎并不被这些影评人欣赏.) I# z. X4 T9 Y* @6 a- e
, q$ C1 w$ w; p& H$ K6 X1 w" E
[ Last edited by lwang on 2005-8-6 at 08:03 ]

467

主题

1401

回帖

3361

积分

★VIP會員★

蔷花嬖人,桔梗同人,慕昭狂人

积分
3361
发表于 2005-8-6 11:24 | 显示全部楼层
目前截止,,<那时代,那些人>的确是上半年的翘楚之作!!, s& Q# H) ^8 {- h
他们对<哭泣的拳头>评价不错,但个人感觉真是一般啊!!柳没什么特色!
此时无声胜有声

7

主题

296

回帖

346

积分

青铜长老

积分
346
 楼主| 发表于 2005-8-7 10:28 | 显示全部楼层
<亲切的金子>也许会是下半年最重要的作品了. 就目前所知道的这些有名的导演的作品来看,也就这部值得看了.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

联系我们|手机版|小黑屋|韩剧社区 ( 蜀ICP备14001718号 )

JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!JS of wanmeiff.com and vcpic.com Please keep this copyright information, respect of, thank you!

GMT+8, 2025-4-10 10:33 , Processed in 0.045101 second(s), 23 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.5

© 2001-2025 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表