|
|
楼主 |
发表于 2003-11-8 15:32
|
显示全部楼层
Originally posted by catcatcat at 2003-10-26 01:01 PM:3 H8 `" |& J- i- t/ k5 T
阿韩真好，谢谢拉 / {$ j8 M4 _/ F2 ^& Y% ~- v* r
故事不错，看了后觉得这真不算恐怖片（虽然对我个人来讲还是恐怖拉），典型的悬念片
2 x4 l( n* e; {0 V就像作者说的，跟《美丽心灵》比较像, B, o! Z1 w- D
8过这个作者也真罗嗦，你特地留的空都白留了，他前面还讲一通废话 ...
) ? ?/ ]4 }$ Z* R
8 a1 F) F; |, a下文是对Drsheep那篇的回复，看看吧~
, z7 v$ z! q6 m# h, q
% \& q0 V/ W8 g作者：Limey Ninja ; H$ h, c- i+ }0 H- o
I think one of the strengths of the film is that it is ambiguous. You can watch this movie repeatedly, and you will spot something new that will alter your idea of what happened. Although in the review, you state that she is just crazy, there are things that point to it perhaps being a hybrid of her being crazy and the house really being haunted. The obvious one being the end, and also the Sister in-law seeing the girl under the sink. Yet, if you think that no ghosts are involved, why do you compare it to The Others. I would not compare it to either the Others or a Beautiful Mind. After watching both of those movies just once, you know exactly what happened, everything is explained, and leaves no room for your imagination to wonder, while Tale of Two Sisters is the exact opposite. Plus, a Beautiful Mind just wasn't very good, and Fight Club touched on the same end revelation before it. A Tale of Two Sisters was a great film, and deserves 9 out of 10.
1 h4 g7 f$ _1 F" e8 qAnd Ju-On was not overrated. It is one of the most original horror films to be made in the last 10 years.5 U' X: W5 k" K% f: ?. S$ v
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~" j1 Z: V0 {# s( o. d
另外，这里第24楼还有很多粉建设性的观点：http://www.krdrama.com/bbs/viewt ... ghlight=&page=2* G& ~$ r$ V- O7 E$ i5 e7 ^* `
3 l1 o' W/ H# M比如，TOMG的。他认为所有一切都发生在秀薇的脑海中，是秀薇在医院里的回想。她的回想中有些是真实的片段，有些是出于报复心理的幻想。所以片中根本不存在任何灵异事件。他对衣柜衣服的解释也蛮有趣的说~
! H* i4 @# q! t$ p( n% F但偶还是比较赞同Joyce、mjcampagna、wuken等的观点~. I7 T1 w f* |, b$ |( W# F
你们认为呢？ |
|
匿名
发表于 2003-10-26 16:43
）
（恐怖的BT的就表说拉）